← All Bills

A1628

An act to amend the Public Buildings Law — 2023-05-17 · Calendar #766

The New York State Senate passed A1628, an act to amend the Public Buildings Law, by a vote of 53-8 after rejecting a proposed amendment addressing local control and protection of vulnerable shelter residents. The amendment, offered by Sen. Lanza on behalf of Sens. Weber and Rolison, would have clarified that local emergency declarations supersede state orders and would have protected individuals in motels and shelters from displacement when migrants are relocated. Acting President Bailey ruled the amendment nongermane under Senate rules; an appeal of that ruling failed on a show of hands vote of 21 ayes. Sen. Rolison cited a recent incident at the Crossgates Motel in Newburgh where veterans were displaced without warning when migrants arrived from New York City, arguing the amendment was necessary to prevent such humanitarian crises. The bill was subsequently restored to the noncontroversial calendar and passed. Eight senators voted against the measure: Ashby, Borrello, Felder, Oberacker, O'Mara, Stec, Tedisco, and Walczyk.
Passed Senate Ayes: 53 · Nays: 8

Debate Summary

The Senate debated a proposed amendment to A1628 that would establish local control over state emergency declarations and protect vulnerable individuals in shelters from displacement when migrants are relocated. Sen. Weber argued the amendment was germane because the bill addresses state leasing of buildings for migrants, and that local governments like Rockland County lack resources to house migrants. Sen. Rolison detailed an incident at the Crossgates Motel in Newburgh where veterans were displaced without warning when migrants arrived, arguing the amendment would prevent such humanitarian crises. Acting President Bailey ruled the amendment nongermane; an appeal of the ruling failed 21-to-unknown, and the bill was restored to the noncontroversial calendar and passed.

Recorded Votes

Individual vote records shown here are captured from roll call mentions in floor transcripts. Because most bills pass with unanimous or near-unanimous ayes, only dissenting (nay) votes are typically read into the record — so the table below skews toward no votes. The full tally (ayes/nays above) reflects the official count.

Senator Vote Party
Ashby nay Republican
Borrello nay Republican
Felder nay Democrat
O'Mara nay Republican
Oberacker nay Republican
Stec nay Republican
Tedisco nay Republican
Walczyk nay Republican

Amendments

Sponsor Description Outcome
Sen. Lanza Two-part amendment: (1) clarify that local states of emergency supersede state emergency declarations issued by the Governor when in conflict, restoring local control; (2) protect vulnerable individuals currently in motels, hotels, or homeless shelters from displacement when migrants are relocated to those facilities. ruled nongermane and out of order; appeal of ruling defeated