← All Bills

A3694A

An act to amend the Education Law — 2023-05-16 · Calendar #241

Assembly Print 3694A, sponsored by Assemblymember Rosenthal and relating to amendments to the Education Law, was laid aside on the Senate floor following a motion by Sen. Lanza. The bill did not proceed to a vote.

Debate Summary

No debate occurred. Sen. Lanza moved to lay the bill aside, and the motion was granted by the Acting President.


An act to amend the Education Law — 2023-05-16 · Calendar #241

The Senate passed legislation requiring New York colleges and universities that receive state aid to report hate crime incidents on their websites, modernizing disclosure requirements currently limited to college catalogs. The bill, sponsored by Assemblywoman Rosenthal and championed by Sen. Stavisky, passed 62-0 on a roll call vote. The measure faced a procedural challenge when Sen. Rhoads proposed an amendment to expand judicial discretion in setting bail for all hate crimes, citing a 47 percent increase in hate crimes since 2019. Acting President Bailey ruled the amendment nongermane, and an appeal of that ruling failed 21-0 on a show of hands vote. Supporters of the underlying bill argued it provides necessary transparency and data-driven solutions to address rising hate crimes on campuses, while Sen. Rhoads, voting for the bill, characterized it as an important but incomplete response to the broader problem of hate crimes in the state.
PASSED Ayes: 62 · Nays: 0

Debate Summary

The bill requires New York colleges and universities receiving state aid to report hate crime incidents on their websites rather than only in college catalogs. Sen. Rhoads attempted to propose an amendment to expand bail eligibility for hate crimes, arguing that judges need discretion to set bail for all hate crimes given rising hate crime statistics. The amendment was ruled nongermane by the presiding officer. Supporters argued the bill provides necessary transparency and data-driven solutions to campus hate crimes, while acknowledging it represents only one component of addressing the broader issue.

Amendments

Sponsor Description Outcome
Sen. Rhoads Amendment to add all hate crimes to the list of qualifying offenses for bail, allowing judges to set bail for any offense charged as a hate crime, not just specific enumerated offenses defeated