S1448A
An act to amend the Education Law — 2023-05-08 · Calendar #404
The Senate passed S1448A, a bill to amend the Education Law establishing a task force on school transportation safety, by a vote of 61-0 on the noncontroversial calendar. The bill's passage came after the chamber rejected an appeal of the presiding officer's ruling that an amendment was nongermane. Sen. Helming had proposed an amendment requiring minority leader appointments to all legislatively enacted task forces and workgroups, arguing such representation was essential to ensure proportional legislative input on bodies that collect data and make recommendations influencing legislative and budget priorities. Helming contended the amendment was directly germane to the bill's creation of a school transportation safety task force and would provide a necessary check on executive authority by ensuring legislative appointees matched gubernatorial appointees in number. Acting President Persaud ruled the amendment out of order, and when Helming appealed, only 21 senators voted to overturn the chair's ruling. The bill then proceeded to passage without amendment.
PASSED
Ayes: 61
· Nays: N/A
Debate Summary
Sen. Helming appealed the presiding officer's ruling that an amendment was nongermane, arguing the proposed amendment requiring minority leader appointments to legislatively enacted task forces and workgroups was directly relevant to the bill's establishment of a school transportation safety task force. Helming contended that legislative workgroups should have proportionally equal representation from majority and minority conferences, and that such representation ensures New Yorkers' equal legislative representation is reflected in task force composition. The appeal was unsuccessful, with only 21 senators voting to overturn the chair's ruling.
Amendments
| Sponsor | Description | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Sen. Helming | Would require appointees of the Minority Leader of the Senate and Minority Leader of the Assembly to be included in all legislatively enacted workgroups, task forces, commissions, and committees, and ensure the number of legislative appointees is proportionally equivalent to gubernatorial appointees. | defeated |