← All Bills

S1851

An act to amend the Public Service Law — 2023-03-23 · Calendar #231

The New York State Senate passed legislation sponsored by Sen. Hinchey to eliminate estimated billing practices by utility companies across the state. The bill, which received 59 affirmative votes, requires utilities to provide accurate meter readings and bills every month rather than alternating between actual and estimated charges. Sen. Hinchey explained that the current practice of estimated billing has resulted in customers receiving inflated bills that often far exceed amounts actually owed, causing account overdrafts even though credits are issued later. She credited community advocates, including Ulster County Human Rights Commissioner Tyrone Wilson, with bringing the issue to lawmakers' attention. Sen. Murray supported the measure while noting ongoing concerns about smart meter installation policies, which he said are affecting ratepayers differently across the state—with some regions being told smart meters will reduce rates while others face penalties for refusing installation. Both senators indicated additional utility company practices may require legislative attention in the future.
PASSED Ayes: 59 · Nays: N/A

Debate Summary

The bill eliminates estimated billing practices by utility companies and requires accurate meter readings and bills monthly. Sen. Hinchey explained that utilities had been sending estimated bills in alternating months rather than actual readings, resulting in inflated charges that overdrafted customer accounts. Sen. Murray supported the bill while noting ongoing concerns about smart meter installation policies and penalties affecting ratepayers differently across regions of the state.