← All Bills

S1870A

An Act to Amend the Public Housing Law — 2024-03-21 · Calendar #492

The Senate passed S1870A, sponsored by Sen. Cleare, amending the Public Housing Law to allow prospective tenants of rent-stabilized and rent-controlled apartments to obtain 50-year rental histories dating back to 1974. The bill passed 43-17, with 17 Republicans voting in opposition. Sen. Martins questioned implementation details, seeking clarification that the bill would not impose additional obligations on property owners to produce records, and confirmed that tenants would request histories from HCR rather than directly from landlords. Martins expressed support for the transparency measure but pivoted to broader housing policy, advocating for means-testing rent-stabilized units, noting that over 30 percent of 1.1 million such units are occupied by people earning above area median income. Sen. Cleare emphasized that rent-stabilized tenants earn a median of $47,000 annually and pay 36 percent of income in rent, and that transparency is essential given historical fraud and collusion in rent pricing.
PASSED Ayes: 43 · Nays: 17

Debate Summary

The bill was initially laid aside on the noncontroversial calendar. When called on the controversial calendar, Sen. Martins questioned the sponsor about implementation details. The bill would require prospective tenants of rent-stabilized and rent-controlled apartments to be able to obtain 50-year rental histories dating back to 1974. Martins sought clarification on who would be responsible for providing records—HCR or property owners—and whether landlords would face obligations to produce documents they may not possess. Sen. Cleare confirmed that HCR currently maintains these records and that tenants would request them from HCR, not directly from landlords. Martins expressed support for transparency without imposing additional burdens on property owners. He then pivoted to broader housing policy, noting that over 30 percent of the 1.1 million rent-stabilized units are occupied by people earning above area median income, and advocated for means-testing these units to make them available to those with genuine need. Sen. Cleare explained the bill's purpose, noting that rent-stabilized tenants earn a median of $47,000 annually and pay 36 percent of income in rent, and that transparency regarding rent history is essential given historical fraud and collusion in rent pricing.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Borrello nay Republican
Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick nay Republican
Griffo nay Republican
Helming nay Republican
Lanza nay Republican
Mattera nay Republican
Murray nay Republican
O'Mara nay Republican
Oberacker nay Republican
Ortt nay Republican
Palumbo nay Republican
Rhoads nay Republican
Scarcella-Spanton nay Democrat
Stec nay Republican
Tedisco nay Republican
Weber nay Republican
Weik nay Republican

An act to amend the Public Housing Law — 2023-06-07 · Calendar #886

The New York State Senate passed legislation requiring landlords to disclose rent history to prospective tenants of rent-regulated and stabilized apartments. Senate Print 1870A, sponsored by Sen. Cleare, passed on a 40-21 vote. The bill aims to increase transparency in the rental market and prevent fraud and coercion in rent pricing. Sen. Cleare argued that tenants currently lack critical information about apartment rent history before signing leases, and that disclosure requirements would hold landlords accountable and protect housing as a human right. The measure takes effect immediately. The bill drew opposition from 21 senators, primarily Republicans, though the Democratic-controlled chamber secured passage with support from 40 members.
PASSED Ayes: 40 · Nays: 21

Debate Summary

Sen. Cleare argued that the bill promotes transparency in rent-regulated and stabilized apartments by requiring landlords to disclose rent history to prospective tenants. She contended that tenants currently lack information about apartment rent history before signing leases, and that transparency is necessary to prevent fraud, coercion, and accountability for landlords. She framed housing as a human right that should not be subject to the highest bidder or unscrupulous pricing practices.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Ashby nay Republican
Borrello nay Republican
Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick nay Republican
Gallivan nay Republican
Griffo nay Republican
Helming nay Republican
Lanza nay Republican
Martins nay Republican
Mattera nay Republican
Murray nay Republican
O'Mara nay Republican
Oberacker nay Republican
Ortt nay Republican
Palumbo nay Republican
Rhoads nay Republican
Rolison nay Republican
Stec nay Republican
Tedisco nay Republican
Walczyk nay Republican
Weber nay Republican
Weik nay Republican