S206B
An act to amend the Judiciary Law ("Jury of Our Peers" bill) — 2024-06-06 · Calendar #1881
The New York State Senate passed the "Jury of Our Peers" bill (S206B, Calendar 1881) on a 39-22 vote, restoring jury service eligibility to individuals convicted of felonies who have completed their sentences. The measure, sponsored by Sen. Cleare, eliminates New York's lifetime ban on jury service for formerly incarcerated individuals, bringing the state in line with nearly half the nation. Cleare argued the existing law is unjust and counterproductive, noting that formerly convicted individuals who have become attorneys can argue cases before juries but cannot serve on them. She cited the example of an elected Assemblyman barred from jury service despite his eligibility for the Judiciary Committee. Cleare emphasized that jury service represents the "quintessential act of civic life" and that rehabilitation and reintegration into society are inextricably linked to the opportunity to contribute to the community. The bill passed with support from the Democratic majority, while 22 senators voted in opposition. Cleare credited Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins, counsel Eric Katz, and Assembly member Jeffrion Aubry for their work on the legislation.
PASSED
Ayes: 39
· Nays: 22
Debate Summary
Sen. Cleare argued that New York's lifetime ban on jury service for individuals convicted of felonies is unjust and counterproductive to rehabilitation and civic participation. She noted that formerly incarcerated individuals who have become attorneys can argue cases before juries but cannot serve on them, and cited the example of an elected Assemblyman barred from jury service despite his eligibility for the Judiciary Committee. Cleare contended the bill aligns New York with nearly half the states that restore jury service rights and ensures that people can be judged by peers with similar lived experiences.
Recorded Votes
Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.
| Senator | Vote | Party |
|---|---|---|
| Cleare | aye | Democrat |
| Ashby | nay | Republican |
| Borrello | nay | Republican |
| Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick | nay | Republican |
| Gallivan | nay | Republican |
| Griffo | nay | Republican |
| Helming | nay | Republican |
| Lanza | nay | Republican |
| Martinez | nay | Democrat |
| Martins | nay | Republican |
| Mattera | nay | Republican |
| Murray | nay | Republican |
| O'Mara | nay | Republican |
| Oberacker | nay | Republican |
| Ortt | nay | Republican |
| Palumbo | nay | Republican |
| Rhoads | nay | Republican |
| Rolison | nay | Republican |
| Scarcella-Spanton | nay | Democrat |
| Stec | nay | Republican |
| Tedisco | nay | Republican |
| Weber | nay | Republican |
| Weik | nay | Republican |