← All Bills

S2297

An act to amend the General Municipal Law — 2024-02-28 · Calendar #280

The New York State Senate passed S2297, sponsored by Senator Mayer, an act to amend the General Municipal Law. The bill received 62 affirmative votes in a roll call vote and will take effect 90 days after becoming law. No floor debate was recorded on the measure.
Passed Senate Ayes: 62 · Nays: N/A

Debate Summary

No debate was recorded on this bill. The measure proceeded directly to a roll call vote following the reading of the final section.


An act to amend the General Municipal Law — 2023-03-27 · Calendar #297

The New York State Senate debated S2297, sponsored by Sen. Mayer, which would amend the General Municipal Law to authorize county comptrollers to conduct audits of Industrial Development Agency (IDA) and Local Development Corporation (LDC) projects. During floor debate, Sen. Murray questioned whether the measure would create redundant oversight, noting that IDAs and LDCs already conduct annual financial audits with results reported to the Public Authorities Reporting Information System (PARIS) and posted on their websites. Murray also pointed out that both the State Comptroller and the Authority Budget Office already possess audit authority over these entities, with the State Comptroller conducting six audits in 2022, five in 2021, and two in 2020. Despite expressing concerns about duplication of services, Murray announced support for the bill, saying he backed increased transparency and "opening up the books." He suggested the Legislature might consider future amendments to tighten the bill's language to limit county comptroller audits to cases where previous audits have already identified problems warranting deeper investigation. Following the debate, Sen. Gianaris moved to restore the bill to the noncontroversial calendar, and the presiding officer agreed. The bill was not voted on during this session segment.

Debate Summary

Sen. Murray questioned Sen. Mayer about the bill's authorization for county comptrollers to conduct audits of IDA (Industrial Development Agency) and LDC (Local Development Corporation) projects. Murray noted that IDAs and LDCs already undergo annual financial audits with results reported to PARIS and posted on websites, and that both the State Comptroller and Authority Budget Office already have audit authority. Despite these concerns about duplication, Murray indicated support for increased transparency and announced he would vote yes, while suggesting potential amendments to tighten language and limit audits to cases where previous audits identified problems.


An act to amend the General Municipal Law — 2023-03-27 · Calendar #297

The New York State Senate passed legislation Tuesday that would authorize county comptrollers and chief county fiscal officers to audit Industrial Development Agencies and Local Development Corporations, marking a bipartisan effort to increase accountability in tax incentive deals. Senate Print 2297, sponsored by Sen. Mayer, passed on a 62-0 vote. The bill would give local officials the ability to scrutinize specific development projects for potential taxpayer harm, addressing concerns that the State Comptroller's office lacks capacity to adequately oversee the roughly 4,200 active projects worth $100 billion managed by 109 IDAs and 279 LDCs statewide. Sen. Mayer noted the State Comptroller audited only six IDAs in 2022, five in 2021, and two in 2020. Sen. Skoufis distinguished the measure from transparency-focused legislation, arguing that while transparency is important, accountability mechanisms are essential to prevent bad deals that harm taxpayers. The New York School Boards Association supported the bill, citing its relevance to school district budgets affected by tax abatement agreements. The bill takes effect 90 days after becoming law.
Passed Senate Ayes: 62 · Nays: N/A

Debate Summary

The bill would authorize county comptrollers and chief county fiscal officers to conduct local audits of Industrial Development Agencies (IDAs) and Local Development Corporations (LDCs). Supporters argued the measure provides necessary accountability for tax incentive deals affecting thousands of projects worth $100 billion, noting the State Comptroller audits only a handful of IDAs annually. The bill distinguishes between transparency measures and accountability mechanisms, with proponents emphasizing that county comptrollers can scrutinize specific projects for potential taxpayer harm.