Public Protection/General Government Budget Bill - an act to amend Chapter 887 of the Laws of 1983 —
2025-05-07
· Calendar #966
The New York State Senate passed its Public Protection and General Government budget bill on a 41-21 party-line vote, with all 21 nays coming from Republicans who criticized the measure for failing to address corrections officer staffing crises and prison safety concerns.
The bill, Senate Print 3005C, includes pension enhancements for various law enforcement agencies including SUNY Police, Park Police, and DEC Forest Rangers—a 20-year retirement benefit long sought by these groups. However, the measure notably excludes corrections officers despite their recent wildcat strike and ongoing staffing shortages.
Republican senators, led by Sen. Stec and Sen. Helming, argued the bill represents a "monumental lost opportunity" to address the underlying causes of the February-March corrections officers' strike. They pointed to documented increases in assaults on staff and inmates since the HALT solitary confinement law took effect, seven inmate deaths from overdoses in 2024 attributed to contraband, and a loss of approximately 2,000 corrections officers since the strike began.
Sen. Stec noted the state has allocated $535 million for emergency correctional facility response costs and currently deploys 3,115 National Guard members in prisons. He criticized the bill for failing to mandate use of body scanners to prevent contraband and for not reforming the HALT law, which he argued was the primary driver of the strike.
The bill also includes controversial provisions on campaign finance reform, Attorney General discovery obligations, and AI-generated child sexual abuse material. Democrats defended the measures as necessary policy improvements, while Republicans raised concerns about campaign finance changes that they argued undermine the original goal of reducing big money in politics.
The measure now moves to the Assembly for consideration.
Passed Senate
Ayes: 41
· Nays: 21
Debate Summary
Extensive debate focused on corrections officer staffing, prison safety, contraband prevention, and the HALT solitary confinement law. Republicans criticized the bill for failing to address the causes of the February-March corrections officers' wildcat strike, including unsafe working conditions, contraband issues, and lack of retirement benefits parity with other law enforcement. Democrats defended the budget as addressing multiple priorities while noting that some proposals, like HALT reform, were not accepted by the Executive. Significant debate also occurred on campaign finance reforms (Part OO), Attorney General discovery provisions (Part RR), AI-generated child sexual abuse material (Part L), and law enforcement pension enhancements.
Transcript Mentions
These votes were extracted from the floor transcript by AI. NYS Senate roll calls are read in full, but AI extraction may not capture every senator — so this list is incomplete and skews toward named dissenting votes. Use the Official API Data table above for the complete roll call.
| Senator |
Vote |
Party |
| Ashby |
nay
|
Republican |
| Borrello |
nay
|
Republican |
| Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick |
nay
|
Republican |
| Gallivan |
nay
|
Republican |
| Griffo |
nay
|
Republican |
| Helming |
nay
|
Republican |
| Lanza |
nay
|
Republican |
| Martins |
nay
|
Republican |
| Mattera |
nay
|
Republican |
| Murray |
nay
|
Republican |
| O'Mara |
nay
|
Republican |
| Oberacker |
nay
|
Republican |
| Ortt |
nay
|
Republican |
| Palumbo |
nay
|
Republican |
| Rhoads |
nay
|
Republican |
| Rolison |
nay
|
Republican |
| Stec |
nay
|
Republican |
| Tedisco |
nay
|
Republican |
| Walczyk |
nay
|
Republican |
| Weber |
nay
|
Republican |
| Weik |
nay
|
Republican |