← All Bills

S4099

An act to amend the Environmental Conservation Law — 2023-06-07 · Calendar #1143

The New York State Senate passed legislation sponsored by Sen. Kennedy that prohibits killing wild animals in contests, competitions, tournaments, and derbies for prizes and entertainment, with a vote of 46-15 on Calendar Number 1143, Senate Print 4099. The bill amends the Environmental Conservation Law to prevent what Kennedy called the "wanton waste" of wildlife resources, while explicitly preserving legitimate hunting for food and population control. Kennedy emphasized the measure does not constitute a hunting ban and aligns New York with other states that have enacted similar protections. "This simply says that the wanton waste of wildlife, one of our state's most precious resources, shouldn't continue," Kennedy said. Opponents, led by Sen. Oberacker, argued that wildlife contests serve legitimate dual purposes, including fundraising for volunteer fire departments and community gatherings, and that the bill fails to address wildlife management concerns such as predator population control. Oberacker, an outdoorsman and farmer, expressed concern about coyote populations and contended the measure overlooks important uses of these events. The bill takes effect November 1.
Passed Senate Ayes: 46 · Nays: 15

Debate Summary

The bill prohibits killing wild animals in contests, competitions, tournaments, or derbies for prizes and entertainment, while explicitly preserving legitimate hunting for food and population control. Sen. Kennedy argued the measure prevents inhumane waste of wildlife resources without banning hunting itself. Sen. Oberacker opposed the bill, contending that wildlife contests serve dual purposes including fundraising for volunteer fire departments and wildlife management, particularly regarding predator population control.

Recorded Votes

Individual vote records shown here are captured from roll call mentions in floor transcripts. Because most bills pass with unanimous or near-unanimous ayes, only dissenting (nay) votes are typically read into the record — so the table below skews toward no votes. The full tally (ayes/nays above) reflects the official count.

Senator Vote Party
Kennedy aye
Ashby nay Republican
Borrello nay Republican
Gallivan nay Republican
Griffo nay Republican
Helming nay Republican
Hinchey nay Democrat
Lanza nay Republican
O'Mara nay Republican
Oberacker nay Republican
Ortt nay Republican
Ryan nay
Scarcella-Spanton nay Democrat
Stec nay Republican
Tedisco nay Republican
Walczyk nay Republican