← All Bills

S6162

An act to amend the Executive Law — 2024-04-16 · Calendar #652

The New York State Senate passed legislation Tuesday that would reform color blindness screening for law enforcement careers, allowing individuals with certain types of color blindness to qualify for service through more nuanced testing rather than blanket disqualification. Senate Print 6162, sponsored by Sen. May, addresses what supporters characterized as an overly blunt testing process that eliminates all individuals with any degree of color blindness, regardless of whether their condition actually impairs critical job functions. The bill would permit those initially screened out to undergo additional testing to determine if their specific type of color blindness—such as distinguishing certain shades of blue—is truly disqualifying. Sen. Oberacker, who has red/green color blindness himself, spoke in favor of the measure, calling it long overdue recognition of an affliction that has been misunderstood. The bill was inspired by Liam Vaitkus, a former session assistant who has color blindness and dreamed of a law enforcement career before discovering the disqualifying nature of current screening. The measure passed 58-1, with only Sen. Brisport voting in opposition. Sen. May pledged to work toward passage in the Assembly.
PASSED Ayes: 58 · Nays: 1

Debate Summary

The bill addresses color blindness screening for law enforcement careers. Sen. May explained that current testing is overly blunt and disqualifies all individuals with any color blindness, regardless of severity. The bill would allow those screened out by initial testing to take a more nuanced test to determine if their specific type of color blindness is actually disqualifying for the role. Sen. Oberacker, who has red/green color blindness himself, expressed strong support for the measure, noting it addresses a long-misunderstood affliction.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Brisport nay Democrat

An act to amend the Executive Law regarding color vision testing requirements for police officers — 2023-06-06 · Calendar #745

The New York State Senate passed legislation amending the Executive Law to modify color vision testing requirements for police officer candidates, allowing those with minor color vision deficiencies to pursue careers in law enforcement. Senate Print 6162, sponsored by Sen. May, passed on a 61-1 vote, with only Sen. Brisport voting in opposition. The bill was developed by Liam Vaitkus, a UAlbany sophomore serving as a session assistant in Sen. May's office. During floor debate, Sen. May explained that while some levels of color vision deficiency should remain disqualifying, many should not prevent individuals from realizing their goal of becoming a police officer. Sen. Bailey and Sen. Rolison both praised the legislation and Vaitkus's work, with Rolison noting that the session assistant had appropriately consulted with relevant organizations before advancing the bill. The measure takes effect immediately.
PASSED Ayes: 61 · Nays: 1

Debate Summary

Sen. May explained that the bill addresses color vision deficiency standards for police officer candidates, allowing those with minor deficiencies to pursue careers in law enforcement while maintaining appropriate disqualifications for more severe conditions. The bill was developed by her session assistant, Liam Vaitkus, a UAlbany sophomore. Sen. Bailey and Sen. Rolison both praised the legislation and highlighted the value of empowering young people to develop policy solutions.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Brisport nay Democrat