← All Bills

S7553

An act to amend the General Business Law — 2023-06-09 · Calendar #1829

Senate Print 7553, sponsored by Sen. Thomas and amending the General Business Law, was laid aside before a vote could be taken. The bill, which would have taken effect 180 days after becoming law, was set aside at the request of Sen. Lanza. No debate occurred on the measure.
LAID ASIDE Ayes: N/A · Nays: N/A

Debate Summary

No debate occurred on this bill. The measure was laid aside at the request of Sen. Lanza before a vote could be taken.


An act to amend the General Business Law — 2023-06-09 · Calendar #1829

The New York State Senate passed legislation establishing transparency and regulatory requirements for auto brokers operating in the state, with a 53-9 vote on Senate Print 7553. Sponsored by Sen. Thomas, the bill requires auto brokers to disclose fees and contractual terms upfront to consumers and mandates that out-of-state brokers sourcing vehicles from New York register and comply with the bill's guidelines. During floor debate, Sen. Rhoads raised concerns about language prohibiting brokers from accepting compensation from multiple parties in a single transaction, comparing it unfavorably to real estate brokerage practices where agents commonly represent both buyers and sellers. Sen. Thomas acknowledged the bill is imperfect and committed to addressing the issue through a chapter amendment after passage. Sen. Weik opposed the measure, arguing it adds unnecessary costs and bureaucratic layers for consumers without adequately addressing complaints about extra fees, and contended brokers should face regulations comparable to real estate agents. Nine senators voted against the bill: Borrello, Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick, Chu, Cooney, Kavanagh, Skoufis, Walczyk, Weber, and Weik.
PASSED Ayes: 53 · Nays: 9

Debate Summary

The bill establishes transparency and regulatory requirements for auto brokers operating in New York State. Sen. Thomas explained that out-of-state brokers sourcing vehicles from New York must comply with the bill's guidelines, while those sourcing from other states do not. Sen. Rhoads raised concerns about language prohibiting brokers from accepting fees from multiple parties in a transaction, comparing it unfavorably to real estate brokerage practices. Sen. Thomas acknowledged the bill is not perfect and committed to addressing the issue through a chapter amendment after passage. Sen. Weik opposed the bill, arguing it adds unnecessary costs and bureaucratic layers for consumers without providing adequate remedies for extra fees, and contended brokers should face regulations comparable to real estate agents.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Borrello nay Republican
Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick nay Republican
Chu nay
Cooney nay Democrat
Kavanagh nay Democrat
Skoufis nay Democrat
Walczyk nay Republican
Weber nay Republican
Weik nay Republican