← All Bills

S8626A

An act to amend the Public Service Law — 2024-06-05 · Calendar #1767

A bill to amend the Public Service Law was laid aside during Senate floor consideration. The measure, sponsored by Sen. Mannion and listed as Calendar Number 1767, Senate Print 8626A, did not proceed to a vote.

Debate Summary

No debate occurred on this bill.


An act to amend the Public Service Law — 2024-06-05 · Calendar #1767

The New York State Senate passed legislation on Tuesday formalizing the process for utility companies that relocate or close call centers, requiring hearings and Public Service Commission approval. Senate Print 8626A, sponsored by Sen. Mannion, passed 53-6 after floor debate centered on concerns about job losses and ratepayer impacts. Sen. Borrello, voting against the measure, warned the bill could force utility companies to move operations out of New York and reduce call center employment as companies turn to artificial intelligence. The sponsor clarified the bill does not impact emergency response capabilities, does not interfere with existing collective bargaining agreements, and allows work-from-home policies subject to union negotiation. Penalties for violations—$50,000 per consumer inquiry and $150,000 per day a call center is closed—are not recoverable expenses in rate cases, Mannion said. Sen. Martins, voting in favor, emphasized the legislation protects jobs for New Yorkers, allowing workers to earn wages and pay taxes in the state. The bill was restored to the noncontroversial calendar before passage.
PASSED Ayes: 53 · Nays: 6

Debate Summary

The bill formalizes the process for utility companies relocating or closing call centers, requiring hearings and PSC approval. Sen. Borrello raised concerns about whether the bill would restrict emergency response capabilities, whether it applies to out-of-state call centers, whether it interferes with collective bargaining agreements, and whether hefty penalties ($50,000 per consumer inquiry, $150,000 per day) would increase ratepayer costs. Sen. Mannion clarified that the bill does not impact emergency situations, does not address staffing levels or current collective bargaining agreements, allows for work-from-home policies subject to collective bargaining, and that penalties are not recoverable expenses in rate cases.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Borrello nay Republican
Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick nay Republican
O'Mara nay Republican
Ortt nay Republican
Rolison nay Republican
Tedisco nay Republican