An act to amend the Public Health Law —
2024-06-04
· Calendar #837
The New York State Senate passed legislation requiring hospitals to involve communities in decisions regarding facility closures or downsizing of critical services, with a 55-5 vote on Senate Print 8843A, sponsored by Sen. Rivera. The bill mandates community notification and stakeholder engagement when hospitals consider closing or reducing maternity, mental health, or substance abuse services. Supporters argued the measure addresses a healthcare crisis in New York, where hospital closures have disproportionately affected underserved communities and left patients without access to critical care. Sen. Gonzalez cited the proposed closure of Mount Sinai Beth Israel in her district as an example of why communities need a voice in these decisions. Sen. Rivera noted the bill has passed the Assembly in previous years and establishes a statewide standard for transparency and community participation in hospital decisions. The measure takes effect 60 days after becoming law. Senators Gallivan, Griffo, Oberacker, Stec, and Weber voted against the bill.
Passed Senate
Ayes: 55
· Nays: 5
Debate Summary
The bill requires hospitals to involve communities in decisions regarding closure of hospitals or vital units providing maternity, mental health, or substance abuse services. Supporters argued that community notification and stakeholder engagement are essential to protect healthcare access, particularly in underserved areas, and that patients and families deserve transparency and a voice in decisions affecting their care. The bill passed the Assembly in previous years and represents the first Senate passage.
Transcript Mentions
These votes were extracted from the floor transcript by AI. NYS Senate roll calls are read in full, but AI extraction may not capture every senator — so this list is incomplete and skews toward named dissenting votes. Use the Official API Data table above for the complete roll call.
| Senator |
Vote |
Party |
| Gallivan |
nay
|
Republican |
| Griffo |
nay
|
Republican |
| Oberacker |
nay
|
Republican |
| Stec |
nay
|
Republican |
| Weber |
nay
|
Republican |