← All Bills

S885C

An act to amend the Real Property Law — 2024-06-04 · Calendar #1683

The New York State Senate passed legislation addressing short-term rental regulation statewide, with a 44-17 vote on Senate Print 885C. The bill, sponsored by Sen. Hinchey, aims to provide data on short-term rentals that have been removed from the housing market and ensure tax parity for municipalities. The measure has support from all 62 counties and major municipal organizations including NYSAC and NYCOM. During floor debate, Sen. Palumbo attempted to attach an amendment known as Karilyn's Law, which would establish visitation rights in guardianship cases and prevent conservatorship abuse. Acting President Bailey ruled the amendment nongermane, and Palumbo's appeal of that ruling was denied. Sen. Krueger emphasized that the bill does not preempt New York City's existing short-term rental authority or prevent the city from modifying its registration system in the future. Sen. Hinchey argued the bill is essential to addressing the state's housing crisis, noting that short-term rentals have removed significant housing stock from the market, particularly in the Hudson Valley and other communities across the state. The bill was restored to the noncontroversial calendar and passed with bipartisan opposition from 17 senators.
PASSED Ayes: 44 · Nays: 17

Debate Summary

The bill addresses short-term rental regulation statewide. Sen. Palumbo attempted to offer an amendment related to guardianship visitation rights (Karilyn's Law), which the Acting President ruled nongermane. Sen. Palumbo appealed the ruling, arguing the amendment addressed access to justice in guardianship cases and cited high-profile cases of conservatorship abuse including Britney Spears and Casey Kasem. The appeal was denied and the bill proceeded. Sen. Krueger emphasized the bill does not preempt New York City's existing short-term rental authority. Sen. Hinchey, the bill sponsor, highlighted that short-term rentals contribute to the housing crisis and that the bill has support from all 62 counties and major municipal organizations.

Recorded Votes

Recorded votes are predominantly dissenting (nay) votes captured from roll call records.

Senator Vote Party
Hinchey aye Democrat
Krueger aye Democrat
Ashby nay Republican
Borrello nay Republican
Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick nay Republican
Gallivan nay Republican
Griffo nay Republican
Helming nay Republican
Lanza nay Republican
Mattera nay Republican
Murray nay Republican
O'Mara nay Republican
Oberacker nay Republican
Palumbo nay Republican
Rhoads nay Republican
Skoufis nay Democrat
Stec nay Republican
Tedisco nay Republican
Weik nay Republican

Amendments

Sponsor Description Outcome
Sen. Palumbo Amendment to establish visitation rights in guardianship cases with a rebuttable presumption in favor of visitation, requiring clear and convincing evidence to deny visitation, and expedited court procedures for visitation orders (Karilyn's Law). defeated