FINANCE
Wire Brief AI
AI-generated summary from the verbatim transcript. Read the full transcript to verify.
NEW YORK STATE SENATE FINANCE COMMITTEE — The New York State Department of Transportation defended its $34.1 billion five-year capital plan during a joint legislative hearing on the 2025-2026 executive budget, with DOT Commissioner Marie Therese Dominguez emphasizing that an additional $800 million in proposed funding is essential to restore the department's purchasing power amid persistent inflation.
Dominguez highlighted major infrastructure projects including the Interstate 81 viaduct removal in Syracuse, the Cross Bronx Expressway reimagining, and the Interstate 787 corridor study in Albany. She reported that the department improved more than 2,800 lane-miles of highways and replaced or rehabilitated more than 3,100 bridges in the previous year. The commissioner also touted the Automated Work Zone Speed Enforcement Pilot Program, which she said has resulted in zero worker injuries or fatalities in areas where it has been deployed since its 2023 launch.
The budget includes $9 billion in projected Transit Operating Aid for statewide transit systems, $100 million in additional non-MTA transit capital funding, and $100 million for the newly announced Zero-Emission Transit Transition Program (ZETT). The department is also investing $25 million to improve rail service in the Hudson Valley and continuing a $230 million Upstate Airport Economic Development and Revitalization Competition.
Sen. Jeremy Cooney, chair of the Senate Transportation Committee, expressed strong support for the $800 million capital plan increase but signaled concern that the 3.4 percent increase in state transit operating aid may be insufficient to meet operational needs. He proposed a new Worker Access Transit Fund to connect underserved communities to economic opportunities and advocated for high-speed rail development, particularly a Toronto-to-New York corridor.
Assemblyman William Magnarelli, chair of the Assembly Transportation Committee, pressed Dominguez on whether the $800 million would be sufficient or if additional appropriations would be needed next year. He also questioned the status of several major projects, including the Interstate 81 viaduct removal in Syracuse, which Dominguez acknowledged would likely extend beyond the originally planned 2028 completion date due to litigation delays.
Assemblyman Brian Miller, ranking member on Transportation, raised concerns about the adequacy of CHIPS funding increases, noting that county and town highway officials are seeking a minimum $250 million increase to address infrastructure decline in upstate New York. The hearing, held February 6 in Albany, included testimony from multiple transportation agencies and is part of a series of joint fiscal committee hearings on the governor's proposed budget.
NEW YORK — The state Department of Transportation defended its $34.1 billion five-year capital plan during a joint legislative budget hearing Wednesday, as lawmakers from Long Island and other regions pressed Commissioner Maria Dominguez on what they characterized as inequitable funding allocations and flat local assistance programs.
Dominguez announced the Governor's proposal to add $1 billion to the capital plan to address inflation, but the move drew criticism from senators who questioned why local programs like CHIPS, PAVE-NY, and BRIDGE NY remain flat despite rising costs. "How can we justify keeping all those flat?" asked Sen. Patrick O'Mara, arguing that municipalities face the same inflationary pressures as the state.
The Long Island funding dispute dominated much of the hearing. Assemblywoman Stacey Solages cited figures showing Long Island receives only 7 percent of the upcoming capital program, down from 23 percent historically. Dominguez disputed the accuracy of those numbers, stating Long Island receives approximately 12 percent of core highway and bridge funding and 15 percent of MOU-subject funding, consistent with historical allocations of 12-16 percent over 15 years. The region is slated to receive $1.5 million over the five-year plan, including $268 million in the memorandum of understanding.
Sen. John Liu praised progress on the state rail plan, noting completion of a Tier 1 Environmental Impact Statement and application for Federal Railroad Administration Corridor ID funding. He asked about potential impacts from the new federal administration on discretionary funding.
Sen. Comrie focused on broadband infrastructure integration with highway projects and praised DOT's responsiveness on regional priorities including Cross Bronx Expressway rehabilitation and Van Wyck Expressway repairs. He noted the agency achieved 18 percent MWBE compliance this year and highlighted a $323,000 federal grant for wildlife crossing studies.
Sen. Oberacker proposed a $62 million "CLEAR" emergency assistance program—$1 million per county—to help municipalities facing 10 percent or greater weather-related impacts to their highway budgets. He also advocated for carveouts on electric vehicle requirements for emergency vehicles, school buses, and plows, citing infrastructure concerns including bridge weight capacity and guardrail strength.
Dominguez stated that electric bus weights fall within existing bridge load standards and require no changes to current practices. She also confirmed that DOT is not seeking to enhance highway capacity and emphasized compliance with the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act through rigorous environmental review processes.
The hearing, held before the Senate Finance Committee, reflected broader tensions between the Executive's capital plan priorities and regional demands for increased local transportation funding.
NEW YORK — The New York State Department of Transportation defended its $34 billion five-year capital plan and climate compliance record during a joint legislative budget hearing on Wednesday, as lawmakers pressed Commissioner Dominguez on funding disparities, work zone safety, and the impact of unfunded mandates on local infrastructure.
The hearing, held before the Senate Finance Committee and Assembly members, revealed significant tensions over how transportation dollars are allocated across the state. Assemblyman Palmesano pointed out that while highway construction costs have surged 70 percent over three years, the CHIPS program for local roads remains flat, and questioned whether the state is prepared to address the impact of an electric school bus mandate that could increase local road maintenance costs by $20,000 to $50,000 per mile.
Commissioner Dominguez emphasized that DOT is leading the nation in transit investment, with $9 billion of the department's budget directed to transit, including $8 billion to the MTA. He noted that just under 1 percent of projects on the Statewide Transportation Plan involve highway widening, countering concerns from Chairwoman Krueger and others that road expansion conflicts with climate goals under the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act.
The commissioner also defended the Work Zone Speed Camera Program, which the state proposes to make permanent. Sen. Cooney raised concerns about a Rochester camera that issued 25,000 tickets in 24 days, but Dominguez said the data shows the program works—violations decrease the longer a work zone is in place—and that revenue from fines goes directly to worker safety initiatives.
On the Cross Bronx Expressway bridge rehabilitation project, Dominguez outlined two approaches: completing work within the existing expressway framework over a longer timeline, or building a temporary diversion road to accelerate construction. Assemblywoman Gallagher questioned whether the proposed "multimodal community connector" is actually a five-lane highway at 45 miles per hour, and raised concerns that NYCHA residents had not been adequately consulted.
Lawmakers from Long Island and the Hudson Valley pressed for greater funding equity, with Assemblyman Durso questioning the methodology for allocating capital funds and Assemblywoman Shimsky requesting an additional $250 million for CHIPS to address the region's aging infrastructure and worst road conditions in the state.
The hearing underscored ongoing friction between the executive branch and legislature over transportation priorities, with lawmakers demanding more accountability on climate compliance, local road funding, and the cumulative impact of state mandates on municipal budgets.
NEW YORK — State transportation officials defended their 2025-2026 budget proposals before a joint legislative committee on Wednesday, with the Department of Transportation and Metropolitan Transportation Authority highlighting significant investments and efficiency gains despite persistent concerns from lawmakers about funding gaps and service equity.
DOT Commissioner Dominguez presented a $6.3 billion capital plan with an additional $100 million for the CHIPS local highway assistance program, but faced pointed questioning from legislators representing rural and suburban areas who said their communities continue to struggle with deteriorating roads despite flat funding levels. Assemblyman Bendett and Assemblyman Slater both pressed the commissioner on whether local highway departments would see meaningful improvements, with Slater specifically asking how the Hudson Valley would benefit from the proposed $800 million allocation.
"When it comes to actually seeing the results in our communities, we just haven't seen that in a meaningful way yet," Slater said, questioning whether the allocation formula would actually change regional distribution patterns.
The MTA presented more optimistic metrics, with Chair Janno Lieber reporting that subways now carry 4 to 4.5 million riders daily—more than the entire U.S. aviation system—and that the agency has reduced its budget 3 percent below pre-COVID levels in real terms while expanding service. The MTA reported dramatic progress on fare evasion, with subway evasion down 25 percent and bus evasion down 12 percent in the last six months.
However, Lieber faced tough questions about the MTA's $68 billion capital program proposal and the $35 billion funding gap for the 2025-2029 plan. Assemblyman Braunstein pressed Lieber on whether the Governor had proposed any solution to the gap, and whether federal partners had been approached for contributions. Lieber pushed back against the term "gap," arguing the capital program is a predictable state budget item like Medicaid and education, and that the Legislature and Governor must determine funding sources.
Assemblyman Braunstein also questioned the MTA on combined fare and toll evasion losses. Lieber said toll evasion costs approximately $150 million annually, with the MTA collecting 96 percent of tolls. He acknowledged the MTA would seek additional enforcement powers this session, including the ability to confiscate license plate devices or vehicles from repeat toll evaders.
Other legislators raised concerns about specific programs. Chair Pretlow questioned whether the $40 million State Touring Route program and $1 million Lower Hudson Valley transit study represented the best use of funds, suggesting more money should go to CHIPS. Assemblywoman Simon raised traffic safety concerns, noting 250 deaths from traffic violence in 2024, including 16-17 children, and asked about DOT support for speed-limiter legislation. Assemblywoman Giglio pressed the DOT on recycled pavement materials and why Long Island cannot use them despite the state's 1988 mandate to promote recycling.
The hearing underscored tensions between urban and rural transportation needs, questions about capital plan financing, and ongoing concerns about transit safety and fare evasion.
The New York State Senate Finance Committee held a joint hearing on the 2025-2026 executive budget for transportation on February 6, with MTA Chair and CEO Janno Lieber defending the agency's spending priorities and addressing pointed questions about police budgets, rail car procurement, and congestion pricing implementation.
Sen. Leroy Comrie opened with a confrontational line of questioning about a reported $20 million cut to the MTA police budget, which Lieber characterized as overtime management rather than a reduction in headcount. Lieber noted that MTA police staffing has actually grown from 1,100 officers in 2021 to 1,350 in 2024, and that the agency lost a $10 million annual grant from the Manhattan District Attorney's office for fare evasion enforcement. The $77 million in funding from Gov. Hochul for NYPD officers on subway trains, Lieber explained, is limited to six months and addresses a different enforcement need.
Comrie also pressed Lieber on transparency, asking whether the MTA's public dashboard would show procurement gains and how residents could track spending on supplies and other operational expenses. Lieber committed to circulating a board presentation detailing the agency's cost-saving measures.
Sen. Roxanne Persaud raised concerns about chronic delays on the BM2 express bus serving Brooklyn, describing her district as a transit desert and criticizing both bus scheduling management and the MTA's customer service call line. NYCT President Demetrius Crichlow acknowledged the issues and offered to examine the specific route.
Assemblyman Simone highlighted a New York Times report that 26 people were pushed in front of subway tracks in 2024, questioning whether the MTA's current platform barriers are adequate. Lieber defended the barriers as effective and noted that the agency plans to expand them from 17 stations to 100 stations in the next year, funded by the Governor.
On procurement, Sen. Tom O'Mara, the Finance Committee's ranking Republican, pressed Lieber on the status of the M-9A commuter rail contract, which has been in procurement for nine years. Lieber said the contract must be resolved within six months. O'Mara also advocated for prioritizing New York State railcar manufacturers, including Alstom in Hornell, CAF in Elmira, and Siemens in Horseheads.
Lieber emphasized that the MTA is proposing to purchase 1,500 subway cars and 500 railcars, and that the agency has reduced construction costs by 3 percent through contract reforms, project bundling, and innovation. He cited the Park Avenue viaduct project in East Harlem as an example, noting it is being rebuilt in 21 months on weekends without shutting down service.
On congestion pricing, Lieber acknowledged that the lower toll rate approved by the state has reduced projected revenue but said the MTA has adjusted its capital plan to accommodate the shortfall. Assemblyman Bores estimated that approximately $5.3 million in revenue has been forgone due to credits for drivers using the Holland or Lincoln Tunnel.
Assemblyman Magnarelli, representing upstate New York, noted the disparity in funding, with the MTA receiving tens of billions while the rest of the state's Department of Transportation capital plan totals $34.1 billion. He urged education efforts to help upstate constituents understand the importance of the transit system to the state's economy. Lieber responded that 85 percent of New York State's personal income taxes and 60-plus percent of sales taxes come from the MTA region, and that 3 million jobs depend on mass transit.
The hearing underscored ongoing tensions between the MTA's capital and operating needs and the Legislature's concerns about cost control, transparency, and equitable funding across the state.
The Metropolitan Transportation Authority defended its proposed $68 billion capital program for 2025-2029 during a joint legislative hearing on the 2025-2026 executive budget on transportation, after the Capital Program Review Board recently vetoed the plan. MTA Chair and CEO Janno Lieber argued the funding level is the minimum necessary to prevent system deterioration and cited studies showing the capital program creates 73,000 jobs with an average salary exceeding $100,000 and generates $112 billion in economic activity. Lieber invoked the "Summer of Hell" of 2017 to illustrate consequences of underfunding, displaying newspaper front pages showing crowded platforms when the system nearly collapsed. The hearing revealed significant regional equity concerns, with upstate and suburban legislators expressing frustration over service disparities. Assemblyman Eachus from Orange County and Northern Rockland County criticized congestion pricing as a "dagger in the heart" for his district, which he said receives only 1 cent back per dollar of payroll taxes paid. Assemblyman Jacobson detailed Orange County's $35.8 million in annual tax contributions while receiving minimal service. Lieber acknowledged that rail service west of the Hudson "stinks" but noted it is operated by New Jersey Transit on freight railroad tracks beyond MTA control. Accessibility emerged as a priority, with Chairwoman Krueger and other legislators pressing for progress on ADA improvements. Lieber reported elevator availability at 97-98 percent and announced plans to make 60 additional stations fully accessible, quadrupling the previous pace. Concerns about congestion pricing's environmental benefits were raised, with Lieber noting preliminary data showing 50 percent reduction in car crashes with pedestrian and cyclist injuries and 66 percent support among regular drivers. The hearing also addressed MTA Police staffing, with Lieber announcing 250 additional officers hired this year—a 20 percent increase—bringing the force to 1,358 officers, while defending a $10 million overtime reduction as part of more efficient workforce management. Questions about Long Island Rail Road new railcars and Interborough Express Project expansion remained unresolved, with Lieber indicating procurement processes preclude detailed discussion but promising resolution within six months on railcars.
New York's transportation agencies defended their 2025-2026 budgets before a joint legislative committee on Thursday, with MTA Chair Janno Lieber facing pointed questions about procurement efficiency and congestion pricing implementation, while DMV Commissioner Mark Schroeder and Thruway Authority Executive Director Frank Hoare highlighted modernization efforts and safety initiatives.
Lieber presented the MTA's $68 billion capital program as essential infrastructure investment, citing recent improvements in on-time performance and ridership growth. He highlighted $800 million dedicated to Hudson Line resilience work to address sea-level rise and landslide risks, and claimed 22 percent cost reductions on elevators and escalators compared to prior programs. The MTA carries 6 to 7 million riders daily, with subways at 80 percent capacity and buses at 90 percent.
However, Assemblyman Blumencranz challenged the MTA's spending practices, citing nearly $700 million spent on consultants for the Second Avenue Subway's first phase compared to $378 million on actual construction. Lieber dismissed the comparison as irrelevant to current practices, noting the project finished eight or nine years ago. He defended the MTA's efficiency record, claiming a 3 percent real budget reduction while providing more service.
Assemblywoman Gallagher raised concerns about $77 million allocated for six months of subway police deployment, arguing the funds could instead support 3,000 permanent supportive housing units. Lieber disagreed, noting that 36 percent reduction in violent subway incidents in January, though he cautioned against attributing it solely to congestion pricing.
Chair Pretlow pressed Lieber on bus schedule adjustments following congestion pricing, noting that buses running on old schedules in faster traffic are effectively slowing down service. Lieber acknowledged the issue and said the MTA is piloting schedule revisions on two or three routes.
DMV Commissioner Schroeder reported the agency generates $2 billion annually for the state and is implementing a $495 million modernization program to replace systems more than 50 years old. He highlighted achievements including the launch of Mobile ID, a record 50 percent enrollment in the organ donor registry, and $8 million in recovered stolen vehicles.
Thruway Authority Director Hoare presented a $1.4 billion 2025 budget and $2.7 billion five-year capital plan, emphasizing safety following two employee fatalities in 2024. The Thruway processed 403 million transactions in 2024 and maintains toll rates significantly lower than Pennsylvania (17 cents per mile) and New Jersey (39 cents per mile). Hoare reported 130,000 work zone speed violations and requested legislative support for making the Automated Work Zone Speed Enforcement program permanent.
Sen. Comrie called for a forensic audit of the MTA to satisfy public concerns about spending and transparency, and advocated for fare discounts to boost ridership. He also raised concerns about the Queens bus redesign, particularly the lack of connections from the Rockaways to JFK Airport and Long Island Jewish Hospital.
The hearing, held February 6, 2025, reflected ongoing legislative scrutiny of transportation spending and service delivery as the state faces competing demands for infrastructure investment across multiple agencies.
NEW YORK STATE SENATE FINANCE COMMITTEE HEARING ON 2025-2026 TRANSPORTATION BUDGET REVEALS CRITICAL GAPS IN EV CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE
Albany — A joint legislative hearing on the 2025-2026 transportation budget exposed significant tensions between New York's aggressive electrification mandates and the state's lack of concrete infrastructure planning, particularly regarding commercial electric vehicle charging along the Thruway.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Frank Hoare acknowledged that zero commercial chargers currently exist on the Thruway system, despite the Advanced Clean Truck Rule already being implemented. While the authority has identified 10 service areas for medium- and heavy-duty chargers, Hoare conceded that utilities have indicated each site would require "the energy and power of a small city," presenting a formidable obstacle to implementation.
Assemblyman Magnarelli delivered a pointed critique of the state's approach, stating: "Not only is this not a plan, this borderlines on ridiculous." He argued that the state is "creating anxiety and fear" in communities by mandating electric vehicle purchases without providing the infrastructure to support them. "We need to know where we're going, and we have to be honest. Right now there's no honesty out there," Magnarelli said.
Senator Tom O'Mara, the ranking member, pressed Hoare on the timeline, noting that the Advanced Clean Truck Rule is already in effect and questioning how trucks will utilize the Thruway without charging infrastructure. Hoare could not provide a specific timeline, citing the complexity of coordinating with utilities and other stakeholders.
On other transportation matters, DMV Commissioner Sheila Schroeder provided updates on the department's IT transformation project. Despite a $170.1 million budget reduction—from $495 million to $324.9 million—Schroeder clarified that the project is not discontinued but rather in execution phase. She outlined two major rollouts: February 2026 for driver-side services and March 2028 for registration services, with funding secured through 2029.
Schroeder also emphasized the urgency of REAL ID compliance, noting that approximately 7 million New Yorkers are currently compliant with only 90 days remaining until the May 7, 2025 deadline. She announced a comprehensive public awareness campaign, including commercials and press conferences at all 13 state airports.
On toll collection, Hoare reported that the Thruway maintains a 96% collection rate, with most unpaid tolls from out-of-state trucking. The authority has secured reciprocity agreements with Massachusetts and is working to expand agreements with New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Ohio, and Illinois. Hoare highlighted that Thruway tolls remain among the nation's lowest at less than 5 cents per passenger mile, compared to 39 cents on the New Jersey Turnpike and 17 cents in Pennsylvania.
Senator Leroy Comrie raised concerns about E-ZPass billing errors and proposed pop-up adjudication centers in all boroughs on weekends, similar to mobile DMV services. He also questioned whether out-of-state vehicle inspections in New York inflate insurance costs for residents.
The hearing underscored a fundamental disconnect between the state's electrification goals and the infrastructure and planning necessary to achieve them, with legislators expressing frustration about the lack of a coherent strategy.
NEW YORK — State transportation officials faced pointed questioning from lawmakers on Wednesday over e-bike regulation, vehicle enforcement, and electric vehicle charging infrastructure during a joint legislative hearing on the 2025-2026 executive budget.
DMV Commissioner Schroeder reported significant progress on moped registration enforcement, citing a sharp increase from 2,317 registered mopeds in 2023 to 7,353 entering 2025 following recent legislation requiring dealer verification of registration and insurance. The commissioner defended the Governor's proposal to reclassify ultra-heavy e-bikes over 100 pounds as mopeds requiring licensing and registration, describing it as a "smart legislation" approach to address public safety concerns in New York City.
However, lawmakers pressed Schroeder on implementation details. Assemblywoman Bailey questioned whether additional requirements like inspections, helmets, and insurance would accompany the licensing mandate. Assemblyman Bores asked what percentage of e-bikes on the market exceed the 100-pound threshold and whether the weight calculation would include batteries. Schroeder acknowledged he lacked specific data and committed to providing more information.
Sen. Liz Krueger raised concerns about out-of-state vehicle registration fraud, noting the longstanding complaint that more cars registered in Vermont appear on New York City streets than exist in Vermont itself. She asked whether new technologies like E-ZPass and congestion pricing data could track vehicles registered elsewhere but present in New York 350 days annually. Schroeder acknowledged the "legitimate question" but said he could not immediately provide an answer.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Frank Hoare faced criticism from Assemblyman Palmesano over the Advanced Clean Trucks regulation requiring electric vehicle charging infrastructure. Palmesano argued the mandate would "destroy the trucking industry," noting that diesel trucks travel 1,800-2,000 miles on a full tank in 20 minutes, while EV trucks can only travel 200 miles in four hours between charges. He called for a pause on the regulation, citing New York's 0.4 percent contribution to global emissions.
Hoare reported 24 completed rest areas with two more opening within weeks and the final renovation in early fall. He acknowledged challenges deploying EV charging for heavy-duty trucks, citing power capacity and space constraints, and noted the Thruway has identified 10 charging sites in cooperation with partners.
On bridge strikes, Hoare reported that a single incident on the South Broadway Bridge in Nyack cost $6 million in lost tolls over 16 hours. An enforcement program yielded 7,000 violations, with 31-32 specifically for over-height violations.
The hearing was held by the Joint Legislative Committee on Finance on February 6, 2025.
New York State legislators heard testimony on the 2025-2026 transportation budget on Thursday, with agency officials and transportation advocates highlighting infrastructure needs and funding gaps across the state's transit, rail, and highway systems.
DMV Commissioner Schroeder defended the Governor's proposed expansion of drugged driving laws, explaining that chemical tests can detect amphetamines, opiates, cocaine, and cannabis, and that over 7,000 trained police officers across the state would enforce the new standards. However, Assemblywoman Simon and Assemblywoman Romero raised pointed concerns about the lack of established impairment thresholds for drugs—unlike the defined blood alcohol content standard—and worried that vague language could catch non-criminal behavior like caffeine consumption. Schroeder acknowledged the concerns and said the state would review the language.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Hoare testified that the Troop C State Police budget costs approximately $71 million annually and is paid for by the Thruway Authority. He acknowledged uncertainty about how speeding ticket surcharges are allocated and expressed openness to testing more reflective lane markings on the Thruway, following Sen. Pretlow's advocacy for a pilot program to improve nighttime visibility and reduce accidents.
Transportation advocates testified on funding priorities. James Morrell of the New York Public Transit Association urged a 15 percent increase in state operating assistance for non-MTA systems and restoration of $26 million in annual NFTA rail infrastructure funding. Mike Burridge of ACEC New York praised the Governor's $800 million NYSDOT capital increase but noted that 65 percent of state bridges and 45 percent of lane-miles remain in fair or poor condition, citing a Federal Highway Administration report. He also noted that highway construction costs have increased 70 percent over three years.
Gary Prophet of the Empire State Passengers Association advocated for funding the New York State high-speed rail Tier 1 EIS (Option 90B), which has been under study since 2010 and was approved as the preferred option in 2023. He also urged increased Amtrak speeds north of Cold Spring, currently at 79 mph but previously 90 mph.
Lisa Daglian of the Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA testified that each billion dollars of MTA capital spending creates 5,900 jobs and advocated for five affordability initiatives, including extending senior discounts to morning peak hours on commuter rails and increasing Fair Fares eligibility to 200 percent of federal poverty level from the current 145 percent.
Sen. Leroy Comrie asked each panelist about their priority projects and emphasized the need for transparency and equitability in transportation systems. He requested another forensic audit of the MTA to demonstrate progress to the public.
NEW YORK — Local highway officials and construction industry representatives urged state legislators on Thursday to add $250 million to the CHIPS program, arguing that inflation has severely eroded the purchasing power of local road funding even as the state proposed an $800 million increase for state highways.
Testifying before the Joint Legislative Committee on Finance during a hearing on the 2025-2026 Executive Budget, highway superintendents and construction groups presented a stark picture of deteriorating roads and bridges across New York. Kevin Hajos, president of the New York State County Highway Superintendents Association, said that with current flat funding and inflation, a mile of road that once cost $100,000 to repair now yields only half a mile of work.
"For smaller towns or counties, this is their budget. This is all they have to repair the road network. This is their lifeblood," Hajos testified.
The testimony revealed significant infrastructure challenges. Local governments manage 87% of the state's public roads, 8,600 bridges, and 97,000 centerline miles of roadways across 1,600 municipalities. Yet the BRIDGE-NY program has funded only 41% of bridge applications and 19% of culvert applications across five rounds.
Colleen Thomas, director of planning and infrastructure for the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe, highlighted a particularly acute problem: State Route 37 in Akwesasne, which carries 15,000 vehicles daily, has not received state DOT funding since 2011. Thomas testified that the tribe receives no state transportation funding, only federal Bureau of Indian Affairs support, despite Highway Law 53 obligating the state to maintain highways on Indian Reservation lands.
Fred Hiffa of Rebuild NY Now raised concerns about emerging costs from climate mandates. He noted that electrifying the state's snowplow fleet—1,600 at DOT and 15,000 at local governments—will cost billions. EV snowplows are estimated at $800,000 each, and utility assessments found that 15% of school bus garages cannot supply enough electricity to charge a single EV bus.
Assemblyman Palmesano cited preliminary research showing electric school buses, which are heavier than diesel buses, could reduce road useful life by 20% and increase maintenance costs by $20,000 to $50,000 per mile.
The construction industry supported the Governor's $800 million DOT increase but emphasized that local roads need proportional investment. Walter Pacholczak of the Associated General Contractors of New York State praised the state funding as addressing inflationary pressures and supporting job creation.
Senators expressed support for the $250 million CHIPS request. Sen. O'Mara called CHIPS "the fairest distribution program" in the state and committed to working hard to achieve the increase. Sen. Comrie pledged to fight for upstate funding and promised to address the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe's road crisis, calling the situation "egregious."
Highway officials also requested consolidation of five local road assistance programs into two to reduce administrative burden on small municipalities, and asked for the bid threshold on highway projects to be raised from $350,000 to $1 million to allow more cost-effective in-house work. However, construction industry representatives opposed raising the threshold, arguing competitive bidding ensures value.
NEW YORK STATE SENATE FINANCE COMMITTEE HEARS TRANSPORTATION BUDGET TESTIMONY ON SALT POLLUTION, AVIATION FUNDING, AND MTA BUS PROCUREMENT
Albany — The New York State Senate Finance Committee held a joint legislative hearing on the 2025-2026 Executive Transportation Budget on Thursday, hearing testimony from industry representatives, county officials, and disability advocates on infrastructure funding, environmental concerns, and transit accessibility.
A key point of contention emerged over the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's bus procurement strategy. John Hroncich of BAE Systems, representing the company's 1,200-plus employees in Endicott, challenged the MTA's capital plan, which includes 1,746 diesel buses and zero hydrogen buses while planning to purchase only 500 battery electric buses. Hroncich argued the plan represents more diesel bus purchases than Boston, Montreal, Toronto, Philadelphia, and Washington D.C. combined purchased over the past decade. He noted that when the MTA buys diesel buses, 76 percent of spending leaves the state, compared to 80 percent retained in-state for hybrid buses manufactured in Endicott.
Sawyer Bailey of AdkAction testified about road salt pollution in the Adirondack Park, citing data showing 64 percent of nearly 500 wells tested exceeded EPA sodium levels. She advocated for reallocating a portion of the $156 million snow and ice management budget to implement sustainable winter road maintenance methods, arguing that a 20 percent salt reduction could be achieved through material spending reductions in a single winter.
Ron Epstein of the New York Construction Materials Association applauded the Governor's $100 million increase for the Core Highway Pavement and Bridge Program and the $250 million addition to CHIPS, but warned of risks including future inflation and borrowing constraints. He noted that vendor-placed paving tonnage is down roughly 50 percent from a year ago.
Mark Heefner of the New York Aviation Management Association testified that New York State airports generate over $80 billion in annual economic activity and support 454,000 jobs, yet the Aviation Capital Grant Program has remained flat-funded at $12.5 million for eight years. NYAMA advocates for a minimum $40 million annual commitment.
Putnam County Executive Kevin Byrne highlighted the congestion tax's impact on county businesses, noting his largest private-sector employer faces a projected $250,000 annual cost. He emphasized that local governments maintain 97,000 centerlane miles of roads compared to 15,000 state-owned lane miles, and own more than half of the state's 17,500 bridges.
Assemblyman Palmesano pressed both Byrne and Epstein on CHIPS flat funding despite a 70 percent Federal Highway Administration-reported construction inflation increase, questioning how counties can maintain infrastructure without increased funding.
Christopher Greif, a disability advocate, testified in support of MTA accessibility improvements, highlighting boarding assistance buttons being tested on Metro-North and Long Island Rail Road, and the NaviLens wayfinding program in Manhattan and Brooklyn.
The hearing underscored tensions between transportation funding needs and budget constraints, with testifiers emphasizing that inflation, environmental concerns, and infrastructure maintenance demands require sustained investment increases.
NEW YORK — Accessibility advocates and state legislators expressed strong support for robust funding of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's capital plan during a joint legislative hearing on the 2025-2026 transportation budget, with testimony focusing on elevator maintenance and accessible station expansion.
Chris Greif, an MTA accessibility advocate who serves on the ACTA committee, testified that the $68 billion capital plan must be fully funded to prevent cuts to accessibility improvements across the transit system. He emphasized that community support is critical to advancing projects, urging residents to submit support letters to the MTA, Assembly, Senate, and Congress to advance accessible station projects including 4th Avenue-Ninth Street and Smith at Ninth Street stations.
Greif highlighted recent progress, noting that Queensboro Plaza accessibility work has been completed and that Broadway Junction Station — described as the most congested accessibility project — is underway, though progressing slowly due to the complexity of coordinating state, city, and federal funding and the need to link to the Long Island Rail Road.
Assemblywoman Deborah Simon raised concerns that insufficient capital funding could delay accessibility improvements, while Assemblywoman Giglio pressed for details on MTA resources for disabled riders, including website information about elevator outages and accessible reroutes. She also inquired about tactile indicators at street crossings and the NaviLens program, a pilot initiative being tested in Manhattan that uses technology to assist blind, deaf, and non-English-speaking transit users.
Greif credited the MTA's Accessibility Division and his collaboration with MTA Accessibility Team member Quemuel Arroyo, arguing that working cooperatively with the agency rather than confrontationally produces better results. He also discussed his creation of accessible reroute protocols to ensure people with disabilities have transit options when service disruptions occur.
Sen. Roxanne Persaud sought updates on Broadway Junction Station progress, while legislators uniformly praised Greif's advocacy work. The hearing concluded at 6:47 p.m.
Topic Summary AI
The joint fiscal committees of the New York State Legislature held a hearing on the Governor's proposed 2025-2026 transportation budget. DOT Commissioner Marie Therese Dominguez testified on the department's $34.1 billion five-year capital plan, including an additional $800 million to restore purchasing power amid inflation, major infrastructure projects like the Interstate 81 viaduct removal in Syracuse and the Cross Bronx Expressway reimagining, and worker safety initiatives. Legislators questioned the sufficiency of funding increases, the status of specific projects, and the adequacy of transit operating aid.
Testimony (60)
Marie Therese Dominguez
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Transportation, Commissioner
AI summary Commissioner Dominguez presented the Governor's transportation budget priorities, highlighting the $34.1 billion five-year capital plan with an additional $800 million to restore purchasing power. She detailed major projects including the Interstate 81 viaduct removal in Syracuse, Cross Bronx Expressway improvements, Interstate 787 corridor reimagining in Albany, and the Rochester Inner Loop Project. She emphasized worker safety initiatives, including the Automated Work Zone Speed Enforcement Pilot Program, and transit investments including $100 million for zero-emission vehicle transitions and $25 million for Hudson Valley rail service improvements.
DOT Commissioner Dominguez
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Transportation
AI summary Commissioner Dominguez presented the DOT's 2025-2026 Executive Budget proposal, highlighting a $34.1 billion five-year capital plan with an additional $1 billion in funding. She discussed ongoing projects including Cross Bronx Expressway rehabilitation and reimagining, Van Wyck Expressway repairs, wildlife crossing initiatives, MWBE program achievements, and regional funding allocations. She addressed concerns about Long Island funding equity, EV infrastructure readiness, and climate compliance.
DOT Commissioner Dominguez
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Transportation
AI summary Commissioner Dominguez provided testimony on the DOT's 2025-2026 budget priorities, including a $34 billion five-year capital plan, climate compliance measures, work zone safety initiatives, and regional infrastructure projects. He discussed the department's approach to evaluating capital projects under CLCPA standards, the use of design-build contracting, and efforts to balance highway maintenance with transit investment and climate goals.
DOT Commissioner Dominguez
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Transportation
AI summary Commissioner Dominguez presented the DOT's role in the 2025-2026 budget, highlighting a $6.3 billion capital plan investment and an additional $100 million for CHIPS funding. He discussed local assistance programs, asset management strategies, recycled materials initiatives, and the department's commitment to climate goals and traffic safety.
Janno Lieber
agency_official
informational
MTA Chair/CEO
AI summary MTA Chair Lieber provided comprehensive testimony on the agency's 2025-2026 budget, addressing questions about police budget reductions, capital spending, rail car procurement, congestion pricing revenue, and operational improvements. He emphasized that the MTA is not cutting police headcount but managing overtime, and that the agency is pursuing cost-reduction strategies in construction and procurement.
Assemblywoman González-Rojas
elected_official
supportive
New York State Assembly
AI summary Expressed support for revisiting the Free Bus Pilot and highlighted the Fair Fares Program as a lifeline for working-class New Yorkers. Questioned why Fair Fares eligibility remains at 145% of federal poverty level when the Blue Ribbon Report on Fare Evasion recommended 200%. Announced intention to share a bill with Senator Comrie to increase the threshold. Asked about the Interborough Express Project status and potential expansion to the Bronx.
MTA Chair/CEO Janno Lieber
agency_official
informational
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
AI summary MTA Chair Lieber presented the agency's capital program and operational priorities, defending the $68 billion capital plan as essential for system maintenance and modernization. He addressed concerns about procurement efficiency, congestion pricing implementation, and specific infrastructure projects including the Hudson Line resilience work. He emphasized that the MTA has improved on-time performance and ridership while maintaining lower fares than comparable systems.
Assemblyman Magnarelli
elected_official
neutral
New York State Assembly
AI summary Magnarelli questioned DMV Commissioner Schroeder about the $495 million appropriation for DMV, which represents a $170.1 million decrease from the prior year. He sought clarification on whether the multiyear DMV IT transformation project was complete or continuing, expressing confusion about the budget reduction. He also pressed Thruway Authority Executive Director Hoare on the lack of commercial EV charging infrastructure along the Thruway, criticizing the state's approach to electrification mandates as creating 'anxiety and fear' in communities without a concrete plan.
DMV Commissioner Schroeder
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Motor Vehicles
AI summary Commissioner Schroeder testified on the Governor's e-bike reclassification proposal, which would classify ultra-heavy e-bikes (over 100 pounds) as mopeds requiring licensing and registration. He reported increased moped registrations following recent legislation and discussed partnerships with law enforcement and tolling agencies to address vehicle compliance issues. He acknowledged questions about out-of-state vehicle registration and vehicle inspection frequency but deferred detailed responses.
DMV Commissioner Schroeder
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Motor Vehicles
AI summary Commissioner Schroeder testified on the Governor's proposed expansion of drugged driving laws in the Executive Budget (TED Part E). She explained that chemical tests can detect amphetamines, opiates, cocaine, and cannabis, and emphasized the role of drug recognition experts across the state. She addressed concerns about vague language regarding impairment definitions and clarified that REAL ID compliance requires multiple forms of identification per federal requirements, not just a passport.
Colleen Thomas
public
supportive
Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe, Director of Planning and Infrastructure
AI summary Thomas testified about the deteriorating condition of approximately 136 miles of local roads under NYSDOT jurisdiction within the Mohawk Territory of Akwesasne. She noted that State Route 37 sees 15,000 vehicles daily but has not received state DOT funding since 2011. She requested annual set-aside funding for NYSDOT, particularly for Franklin County, to fulfill the state's legal obligation under Highway Law 53 to maintain highways constructed on Indian Reservation lands. She emphasized that the tribe receives no state transportation funding, only federal Bureau of Indian Affairs support.
Sawyer Bailey
advocate
opposed
AdkAction
AI summary Bailey testified about road salt pollution in the Adirondack Park, citing data showing 64% of nearly 500 wells tested exceeded EPA sodium levels. She advocated for sustainable winter road maintenance methods and recommended reallocating a portion of the $156 million snow and ice management budget to implement recommendations from the Adirondack Road Salt Task Force Report, including live edge plow equipment and salt brine spreaders.
Chris Greif
advocate
supportive
ACTA Committee / MTA Accessibility Advocate
AI summary Greif testified on MTA accessibility initiatives, emphasizing the need for community support letters to advance accessible station projects. He discussed the importance of the $68 billion capital plan for accessibility improvements and highlighted his work creating accessible reroute protocols when service disruptions occur. He praised the MTA's Accessibility Division and advocated for continued collaboration between advocates and the agency.
MTA Chair and CEO Janno Lieber
agency_official
informational
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
AI summary Chair Lieber presented the MTA's accomplishments and budget proposal, highlighting ridership recovery, service improvements, efficiency gains, and progress on fare evasion. He discussed the $68 billion capital program proposal, efficiency initiatives that reduced the MTA budget 3 percent below pre-COVID levels in real terms, and ongoing challenges with public safety and fare evasion.
Jai Patel
agency_official
informational
MTA Co-CFO
AI summary Co-CFO Patel provided financial details on MTA police staffing and budget, clarifying that the agency lost a $10 million annual grant from the Manhattan DA's forfeiture fund that had been used for fare evasion enforcement over a four-year period.
MTA Chair/CEO Janno Lieber
agency_official
informational
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
AI summary Responded to Fair Fares question, noting MTA support for raising eligibility threshold and focus on enrollment. Discussed Interborough Express Project as connecting two most populous boroughs with limited rail connectivity. Explained that current capital program will fund design and environmental review, not construction. Addressed wheel wear issues on railcars, clarifying investigation is three months old, not three years. Discussed congestion pricing impacts and MTA Police staffing.
DMV Commissioner Mark Schroeder
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Motor Vehicles
AI summary DMV Commissioner Schroeder presented the agency's modernization efforts and operational achievements. He highlighted the $495 million budget allocation for technology modernization, the launch of Mobile ID, improvements in customer service metrics, and safety initiatives including work on ghost plates and toll evasion. He emphasized record improvements in contact center performance and expanded online services.
DMV Commissioner Schroeder
agency_official
informational
New York State Department of Motor Vehicles
AI summary Commissioner Schroeder clarified that the DMV IT transformation project is not discontinued but rather in execution phase, with funding secured through 2029. He outlined two major rollouts: February 2026 for driver-side services and March 2028 for registration services. He also addressed REAL ID compliance, noting that approximately 7 million New Yorkers are currently REAL ID-compliant with a May 7, 2025 deadline, and discussed efforts to combat ghost plates through a task force with law enforcement.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Frank Hoare
agency_official
informational
New York State Thruway Authority
AI summary Director Hoare testified on Thruway operations and infrastructure, including electric vehicle charging deployment, bridge strike prevention efforts, and rest area renovations. He reported 24 completed rest areas with two more opening within weeks and the final one in early fall. He discussed challenges with EV charging infrastructure including power capacity and space requirements for heavy-duty trucks, and noted enforcement efforts against bridge strikes.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Hoare
agency_official
informational
New York State Thruway Authority
AI summary Executive Director Hoare testified on Thruway operations, including speeding ticket revenue distribution, lane marking reflectiveness, and work zone safety. He acknowledged that speeding ticket fines are split between the state and locality but was uncertain about surcharge allocation. He noted that Troop C State Police budget is paid for by the Thruway Authority at approximately $71 million annually and indicated willingness to explore more reflective lane marking technology.
Matt Mustico
elected_official
supportive
Town of Elmira Highway Superintendent, Chemung County; President of New York State Association of Town Superintendents of Highways
AI summary Mustico testified on behalf of local highway superintendents, noting that local governments manage 87% of the state's public roads, half of all bridges, and plow over a quarter of NYSDOT roads. He stated that while the Governor added $800 million to NYSDOT's Core program, local highway and bridge funding remained flat. He requested an additional $250 million for CHIPS to offset inflation impacts on construction costs and requested consolidation of five state local road assistance programs into two programs.
Ron Epstein
industry
supportive
New York Construction Materials Association
AI summary Epstein, president and CEO of the New York Construction Materials Association and former executive deputy commissioner of DOT, applauded the Governor's $100 million increase for the Core Highway Pavement and Bridge Program (30% increase year-over-year) and the $250 million addition to CHIPS. He recommended modernizing state transportation infrastructure priorities, developing comprehensive needs assessments for DOT similar to the MTA, and addressing long-term funding challenges including inflation and borrowing constraints.
Shanifah Reiara
agency_official
informational
MTA Chief Communications Officer
AI summary MTA CCO Reiara testified about the Fair Fares program, describing monthly enrollment activities at transit system locations and plans to use in-station customer service centers for 24-hour enrollment.
Assemblyman Eachus
elected_official
opposed
New York State Assembly, 99th District
AI summary Criticized MTA for three-year negotiations with New York railcar company without resolution on wheel wear issues. Expressed frustration with congestion pricing as harmful to his district (Eastern Orange County and Northern Rockland County), which receives minimal service despite paying significant payroll taxes. Stated district receives only 1 cent back per dollar of payroll taxes paid. Noted district already procured $10 million to double one mile of track and does not need a $1 million study. Made statement for record rather than asking questions.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Frank Hoare
agency_official
informational
New York State Thruway Authority
AI summary Thruway Authority Executive Director Hoare presented the agency's 2025 budget and capital plan, emphasizing safety as a priority following two employee fatalities in 2024. He detailed the $1.4 billion budget, the $2.7 billion five-year capital plan, toll collection enforcement efforts, and infrastructure modernization including electric vehicle charging expansion and service area reconstruction.
Thruway Authority Executive Director Hoare
agency_official
informational
New York State Thruway Authority
AI summary Director Hoare testified on Thruway operations, toll collection, and infrastructure challenges. He confirmed zero commercial EV chargers currently exist on the Thruway and outlined plans to identify 10 service areas for medium- and heavy-duty chargers, noting that utilities have indicated each site would require 'the energy and power of a small city.' He discussed toll rates, fiber optic expansion generating approximately $10 million annually, and toll collection challenges with out-of-state trucking, noting reciprocity agreements with Massachusetts and efforts to expand to other states.
James Morrell
advocate
supportive
New York Public Transit Association; Director of Public Transit, Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority
AI summary Morrell testified on behalf of non-MTA transit systems across upstate New York and downstate suburbs. He advocated for a 15 percent increase in state operating assistance, enactment of the Governor's proposed $219 million capital funding for non-MTA systems, $1 billion over five years for non-MTA capital funding, and restoration of $26 million annual appropriation for NFTA rail infrastructure. He emphasized that increased state aid would result in more transit service, economic development, and help offset loss of federal COVID relief funds.
Kevin Hajos
elected_official
supportive
New York State County Highway Superintendents Association, President; Superintendent of Public Works, Warren County
AI summary Hajos testified on behalf of county highway superintendents, praising the efficiency improvements in the BRIDGE-NY program but noting that only 41% of bridge applications and 19% of culvert applications were funded across five rounds. He requested $250 million increase to CHIPS (bringing it to $848.1 million), maintenance of Extreme Winter Recovery Funding at $100 million, maintenance of State Touring Route funding at $140 million, and support for a combined Pave Our Potholes program at $250 million. He also requested raising the bid threshold from $350,000 to $1 million or eliminating it entirely.
Mark Heefner
industry
supportive
Greater Binghamton Airport, New York Aviation Management Association
AI summary Heefner, president of NYAMA and commissioner of aviation at Greater Binghamton Airport, testified that New York State airports generate over $80 billion in annual economic activity and support more than 454,000 jobs. He noted the Aviation Capital Grant Program has been flat-funded at $12.5 million for eight years and advocated for a minimum state commitment of $40 million annually. He praised Governor Hochul and legislative aviation caucus leaders for recognizing airport capital needs.
Demetrius Crichlow
agency_official
informational
NYCT President
AI summary NYCT President Crichlow addressed questions about wheel wear on the Queens Boulevard line, bus service reliability, and network redesign efforts. He explained that multiple factors including increased speeds, new signaling, and new train cars are being studied to determine causes of accelerated wheel wear.
Chairwoman Krueger
elected_official
supportive
New York State Senate
AI summary Questioned MTA about economic impact of capital program and how much money returns to regional economy. Asked about ADA accessibility improvements and what happens if funding falls below $68 billion. Inquired about congestion pricing environmental impacts and status of $2.3 billion owed by state from 2024 capital appropriation. Noted city recently requested additional bonding authority for $3-4 billion for next program.
Senator Leroy Comrie
elected_official
neutral
New York State Senate
AI summary Sen. Comrie thanked Commissioner Schroeder for DMV innovations and asked technical questions about sufficient resources for the transformation project and REAL ID compliance. He raised concerns about E-ZPass billing errors and proposed pop-up E-ZPass adjudication centers and amnesty programs. He also questioned Director Hoare about high-speed internet expansion and toll comparisons, and raised concerns about out-of-state vehicles being inspected in New York, suggesting this inflates insurance costs for residents.
Mike Burridge
industry
supportive
ACEC New York (American Council of Engineering Companies)
AI summary Burridge testified in support of the Governor's $800 million NYSDOT capital budget increase and advocated for continued infrastructure investment. He cited data showing 65 percent of state bridges and 45 percent of lane-miles are in fair or poor condition. He supported the MTA capital plan, advocated for defining progressive design-build in law, commended work zone safety initiatives, and urged extension of qualification-based selection (QBS) requirements to public authorities.
Walter Pacholczak
industry
supportive
Associated General Contractors of New York State, Vice President of Government Affairs
AI summary Pacholczak testified in support of the Governor's $800 million increase to the DOT Core program, calling it necessary to address inflationary pressures and noting its importance as a job creator and support for small businesses. He highlighted that the funding helps reduce motorist costs for car repairs, accidents, and traffic safety. He supported two legislative priorities: making permanent and expanding the Work Zone Speed Camera Program and closing the Part R loophole to extend enhanced transportation worker protections to highway workers.
John Hroncich
industry
opposed
BAE Systems
AI summary Hroncich, representing BAE Systems' 2,000+ New York employees (1,200+ in Endicott), testified against the MTA's capital plan bus procurement strategy. He challenged the plan's inclusion of 1,746 diesel buses and zero hydrogen buses, noting this represents more diesel buses than Boston, Montreal, Toronto, Philadelphia, and Washington D.C. combined purchased in 10 years. He argued that when the MTA buys diesel buses, 76% of spending leaves the state, versus 80% retained in-state for hybrid buses manufactured in Endicott.
Assemblywoman Solages
elected_official
supportive
New York State Assembly
AI summary Congratulated MTA on one-millionth rider at Elmont Station. Inquired about status of new Long Island Rail Road train cars promised years ago and timeline for delivery. Asked about electrification of Suffolk County rails, including Port Jefferson line and main line extension to Yaphank/Riverhead.
Assemblyman Miller
elected_official
supportive
New York State Assembly
AI summary Assemblyman Miller praised the Thruway Authority for road maintenance and safety, commending the iCone technology pilot program that sends real-time notices to Waze and Google Maps users about snowplows. He asked about realistic timelines for EV charging infrastructure and suggested alternative fuel solutions. He also inquired about fiber manufacturing requirements for state right-of-way leases and asked about EV inspection procedures.
Gary Prophet
advocate
supportive
Empire State Passengers Association (ESPA)
AI summary Prophet testified on behalf of ESPA, advocating for improved intercity and commuter rail service. He thanked the Governor for funding the Livingston Avenue Rail Bridge replacement and discussed Metro-North improvements. He urged increased Amtrak speeds north of Cold Spring (from current 79 mph back to 90 mph), development of a robust state rail passenger plan, and funding for the New York State high-speed rail Tier 1 EIS (Option 90B), which has been under study since 2010 and was approved as the preferred option in 2023.
John Cooney, Jr.
industry
supportive
Construction Industry Council of Westchester and the Hudson Valley
AI summary Cooney expressed full support for the Governor's $800 million increase to NYSDOT's Core program, calling it necessary to restore purchasing power lost to inflation. He pressed for a corresponding $250 million increase to CHIPS, noting that the math on inflationary impact aligns the two figures. He highlighted that NYSDOT Region 8 (Hudson Valley) has the worst road and bridge conditions in the state for a 10-year run and has more lane-miles in bridges than any other region. He endorsed expansion and permanence of the Work Zone Speed Camera Program and expansion of transportation worker protections.
Kevin Byrne
elected_official
neutral
Putnam County Executive
AI summary Byrne, Putnam County Executive and former Assembly member, testified on behalf of Putnam County and Region 8. He noted the congestion tax's detrimental impact on county businesses, including their largest private-sector employer Ace Endico (600+ employees, projected $250,000 annual cost). He highlighted that Putnam County serves under 100,000 people but maintains 83 culverts, 31 bridges, and 116 centerlane miles of county roadway. He thanked the Legislature for $1.2 million in CHIPS funding and advocated for Route 301 improvements and expanded paratransit services.
Assemblywoman Mitaynes
elected_official
supportive
New York State Assembly
AI summary Asked about implementing new bus route connecting Red Hook to Lower Manhattan to serve seniors, students, NYCHA residents, and people with disabilities. Expressed concern that if $68 billion capital program is reduced, it will affect number of accessibility projects. Asked how MTA determines how many projects would not move forward if funding falls below $68 billion.
Senator Tom O'Mara
elected_official
skeptical
New York State Senate
AI summary Sen. O'Mara, the ranking member, pressed Director Hoare on the lack of medium- and heavy-duty charging stations and the challenges of obtaining sufficient electrical power. He questioned the timeline for implementation given the Advanced Clean Truck Rule is already being implemented, and asked about charging times, vehicle range, and safety upgrades needed for heavier electric vehicles. He cited a claim about $350 million in guardrail replacement costs.
Rich O'Malley
industry
supportive
New York Building Congress
AI summary O'Malley testified on behalf of the Building Congress, representing over 500 constituent organizations and 25,000 skilled professionals. He urged full funding of the MTA's five-year capital plan and a robust DOT capital plan. He advocated for investment in major projects including new bridges and road expansions, supported innovative transportation initiatives and sustainable practices, and emphasized the importance of alternative delivery mechanisms for efficiency.
Fred Hiffa
advocate
supportive
Rebuild NY Now
AI summary Hiffa testified in strong support of the Governor's $800 million DOT Core program increase and urged addition of $250 million to CHIPS, noting that local highway aid remained flat year-over-year for the second consecutive year. He detailed the impact of CLCPA mandates, particularly the Clean Trucks Act requiring electrification of snowplow fleets. He noted that DOT has 1,600 snowplows and local governments have 15,000 snowplows and 1,300 garages. He cited utility assessments showing 15% of school bus garages cannot supply enough electricity for a single EV bus, and another quarter cannot supply more than 10 EV buses. He estimated EV plows will cost approximately $800,000 each versus $425,000 for EV buses.
Christopher D. Greif
advocate
supportive
Advocate for people with disabilities, New York City Transit Riders Council, ACTA
AI summary Greif, a disability advocate with 32+ years of experience and NYC Transit Riders Council member, testified in support of MTA accessibility improvements. He highlighted ongoing initiatives including boarding assistance buttons being tested on Metro-North and Long Island Rail Road, the NaviLens wayfinding program in Manhattan and Brooklyn, and OMNY testing. He advocated for continued funding and expansion of accessibility technologies, updated signage, LED lighting, and accessible buses.
Assemblywoman Simon
elected_official
mixed
New York State Assembly, Brooklyn
AI summary Raised concerns about York Street P71 and Access-A-Ride dysfunction, questioning why people must go in-person for disability documentation. Criticized insulting aspects of congestion pricing evaluation process. Asked about elevator issues and why separate lawsuit has not been resolved. Challenged MTA on developer-provided elevators not functioning properly.
Assemblyman Braunstein
elected_official
neutral
New York State Assembly
AI summary Assemblyman Braunstein emphasized the need for greater public awareness of REAL ID requirements and asked detailed questions about ghost plate enforcement. He inquired about the number of security details conducted in New York City and the process for handling defaced plates. He also asked Director Hoare about toll collection challenges with out-of-state trucking and the Tolls by Mail Enforcement Act.
Lisa Daglian
advocate
supportive
Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA (PCAC)
AI summary Daglian testified on behalf of PCAC, created in 1981 to represent riders on NYC subways, buses, Staten Island Rail, LIRR, and Metro-North. She emphasized the importance of fully funding the MTA capital plan, noting that each billion dollars spent creates 5,900 jobs. She advocated for five affordability platforms: extending senior/disabled discounts to morning peak on commuter rails, implementing family fares for 12-17 year-olds, implementing CityTicket Weekly, increasing Fair Fares to 200 percent of federal poverty level, and supporting the Rider Representation Act to give PCAC voting power on the MTA Board.
Assemblywoman Valdez
elected_official
supportive
New York State Assembly
AI summary Noted her district has only one accessible subway station (Court Street) with frequently out-of-service escalators and elevators due to public-private partnership. Asked if private maintenance is part of problem and whether MTA anticipates using more public-private partnerships for accessibility expansion. Inquired about funding needed to prevent future fare increases.
Senator Roxanne Persaud
elected_official
supportive
New York State Senate
AI summary Sen. Persaud commended the DMV team for REAL ID outreach and publicity efforts. She asked for specific numbers on New Yorkers who have not completed REAL ID updates and inquired about the mobile office program, asking how many have been conducted statewide and whether the department is working with counties to expand the program.
Assemblywoman Hooks
elected_official
mixed
New York State Assembly
AI summary Criticized Queens bus redesign for prioritizing airport access over community needs in East Elmhurst, a naturally occurring older community (NORC) and transportation desert. Noted several bus stops were removed and area became two-fare zone. Raised concerns about youth MetroCard issues when cards are stolen or lost, with OMNY payment system declining transactions but charging money later. Asked about MetroCard bus service to underserved areas.
Assemblyman Ra
elected_official
neutral
New York State Assembly
AI summary Assemblyman Ra asked about motor vehicle inspection service stations requesting fee increases, noting the number of facilities has been declining. He inquired about the department's position on increasing inspection fees and asked whether additional inspection criteria would be required for electric vehicles, particularly regarding batteries. He also complimented the DMV on improved customer satisfaction.
Assemblyman Jacobson
elected_official
opposed
New York State Assembly
AI summary Represents both sides of Hudson from Beacon to Poughkeepsie. Asked about flooding issues at Beacon Train Station. Focused on Orange County service complaints, noting low ridership and high subsidy. Provided specific tax contributions: Orange County employers pay $25 million Payroll Mobility Tax, residents pay $8.57 million mortgage tax, $620,000 from Metro-North fees, $146,000 from statewide assistance, and $1.46 million from sales tax. Argued Orange County deserves better service and criticized lack of expansion or updates.
Senator Bynoe
elected_official
neutral
New York State Senate
AI summary Sen. Bynoe asked Commissioner Schroeder about a systemic issue where constituents received tickets after turning in license plates in Suffolk County and Nassau County. She sought clarification on whether this is a widespread problem or isolated incident.
Assemblywoman Giglio
elected_official
skeptical
New York State Assembly
AI summary Questioned why MTA Police budget is being cut when congestion pricing increases ridership and MTA Police is taking on additional responsibilities (Throgs Neck and Whitestone bridges). Noted MTA Police has doubled in size in recent years. Raised concerns about inaccurate pension estimates where retirees have been overpaid and are now asked to repay, with 36-48 month delays in catching up.
Assemblyman Slater
elected_official
neutral
New York State Assembly
AI summary Asked about emergency vehicle exemption plan for congestion pricing, specifically regarding elected officials utilizing exempt vehicles. Inquired whether exemption is limited to Mayor, Comptroller, and Public Advocate. Asked how exemption works and whether E-ZPass tags are used.
Assemblyman Durso
elected_official
skeptical
New York State Assembly
AI summary Questioned MTA Police overtime budget reduction of $10 million and its impact on safety. Expressed concern about worker safety, noting conductors have reported being attacked on trains. Asked how MTA will keep both riders and workers safe with reduced overtime. Inquired about hiring additional MTA police officers to compensate for overtime cuts.
MTA CFO Willens
agency_official
informational
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
AI summary Responded to question about state and city funding commitments. Confirmed both state and city committed $3 billion each to 2020-2024 capital program and have kept their commitments despite COVID delays. Noted city recently requested additional transitional bonding authority for next program.
NYCT President Crichlow
agency_official
informational
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
AI summary Discussed Queens bus network redesign and upcoming Brooklyn bus network redesign to improve service and connectivity to rail systems. Addressed Red Hook bus route request, noting Brooklyn redesign will examine how to provide great service to all neighborhoods. Discussed elevator and escalator performance, noting privately owned equipment performs in mid-80s, up from mid-70s.
MTA Co-CFO Patel
agency_official
informational
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
AI summary Confirmed MTA Police budget is 1358 officers, with previous staffing around 1100 officers.
Senator Engagement AI (59)
| Senator | Engagement | Stance | Focus Areas | Summary AI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assemblyman Bores | moderate | neutral | Amtrak service contracts with incentive structures | Assemblyman Bores asked Gary Prophet about state contracts with Amtrak that include incentives for on-time service and penalties for poor performance, noting Virginia's model as an example. |
| Assemblyman Palmesano | moderate | supportive | CHIPS program funding Inflationary impacts on local infrastructure | Assemblyman Palmesano raised concerns about the flat CHIPS budget proposal despite 70 percent increases in highway construction costs over three years, and asked about inflationary impacts on local communities' ability to address infrastructure needs. |
| Assemblywoman Giglio | high | supportive | Website information for disabled riders about elevator outages Accessible reroute protocols Tactile indicators and braille at street crossings NaviLens program for blind and deaf users | Giglio demonstrated detailed engagement with accessibility issues, asking specific questions about MTA resources for disabled passengers and pedestrians. She emphasized the importance of accessibility for people with disabilities, seniors, and parents with strollers. |
| Assemblywoman Romero | high | skeptical | Vague language in drugged driving proposal Potential for overreach (caffeine example) Substance definition clarity | Assemblywoman Romero expressed concern that the proposed language defining impairment as 'any substance' could be too broad and catch non-criminal behavior like caffeine consumption. She urged reconsideration of the language and suggested focusing on specific controlled substances. |
| Assemblywoman Shimsky | moderate | supportive | Long-term capital investment momentum High-speed rail implementation and costs | Assemblywoman Shimsky asked about maintaining momentum for continued capital investment beyond the $800 million increase and inquired about the magnitude of high-speed rail expenses. |
| Assemblywoman Simon | high | skeptical | Drugged driving enforcement and testing standards Impairment definition and measurement | Assemblywoman Simon asked pointed questions about how impairment from drugs would be measured and tested, noting the lack of established thresholds similar to blood alcohol content, and expressing concern about the scientific basis for the proposal. |
| Assemblywoman Simon | high | supportive | Elevator maintenance and accessibility Impact of $68 billion capital plan funding on accessibility improvements Timeline for system accessibility improvements | Simon expressed strong support for accessibility improvements and concern about potential cuts if capital funding is not secured. She acknowledged Greif's visible advocacy work and emphasized the importance of accurate information in legislative decision-making. |
| Chairman Pretlow | low | neutral | Chairman Pretlow managed the hearing proceedings and made a light comment about MTA standing for 'More Trains Available.' | |
| Chairwoman Krueger | low | neutral | Chairwoman Krueger presided over the hearing and managed testimony flow but did not pose substantive questions. | |
| Sen. Bynoe | moderate | supportive | Long Island flood resilience and aging infrastructure State Touring Routes program participation Electric bus electrification funding | Sen. Bynoe, representing Nassau County South Shore communities, focused on infrastructure resilience for flood-prone areas and inquired about participation in state programs for transit electrification, receiving generally positive responses from the Commissioner. |
| Sen. Bynoe | low | neutral | Long Island Rail Road bridges in Nassau and Suffolk County Manhasset bridge closure Bridge strikes and service reliability | Sen. Bynoe asked about LIRR bridge conditions and jurisdictional challenges with local governments, and inquired about a specific bridge closure in Manhasset. |
| Sen. Bynoe | low | neutral | License plate return and ticket issuance | Sen. Bynoe asked a single question about a constituent issue regarding tickets received after turning in license plates, seeking clarification on whether this is a systemic problem. |
| Sen. Bynoe | low | neutral | DMV system-wide issues affecting constituents | Sen. Bynoe raised a constituent issue about a DMV problem occurring throughout the system and asked about the rectification process. Commissioner Schroeder acknowledged the issue but could not provide immediate details. |
| Sen. Cleare | moderate | supportive | Second Avenue Subway Phase 2 expansion to Broadway Funding for extension to Broadway Accessibility at 125th Street and Broadway station Partnership with Columbia University on elevator installation | Sen. Cleare expressed support for Second Avenue Subway expansion and offered to help advance the project. She raised concerns about accessibility at elevated stations and inquired about Columbia University partnership for elevator installation. |
| Sen. Comrie | high | supportive | Broadband infrastructure integration with highway projects Cross Bronx Expressway bridge rehabilitation and reimagining Van Wyck Expressway repairs and exit closures DOT project transparency and public database access MWBE program effectiveness and vendor outreach Wildlife crossing initiatives and habitat connectivity | Sen. Comrie praised the Commissioner's responsiveness and work over several years. He focused on infrastructure equity issues, particularly broadband access in upstate communities and regional transportation projects in the Bronx and Long Island. He expressed interest in expanding MWBE opportunities and continuing wildlife crossing work. |
| Sen. Comrie | high | skeptical | Design-build procurement projects Department audits and capital project spending Budget completion rates for 2020-2027 capital plans | Sen. Comrie requested detailed information on design-build projects, department audits, and spending completion rates for recent capital plans, signaling oversight concerns about project execution and budget accountability. |
| Sen. Comrie | high | skeptical | MTA police budget cuts and headcount Governor's $77 million NYPD subway deployment Fair Fares program expansion Dashboard transparency and procurement visibility Wheel wear issues on Queens Boulevard line Alstom train procurement Number of subway cars needed | Sen. Comrie engaged extensively with MTA leadership, pressing for clarification on police budget reductions, the duration of state funding, and transparency in spending. He expressed support for Fair Fares expansion and raised concerns about train procurement delays and operational issues. |
| Sen. Comrie | moderate | skeptical | Forensic audit of MTA Frequent user discounts for express buses Weekly CityTicket reinstatement Queens bus redesign Rockaway to JFK connection Long Island Jewish connection Transparency in capital spending Upstate procurement opportunities | Sen. Comrie pressed for greater transparency and accountability, specifically requesting a forensic audit to satisfy public concerns about MTA spending. He advocated for fare discounts to increase ridership and raised concerns about the Queens bus redesign, particularly regarding connections to JFK and Long Island Jewish Hospital. He emphasized the importance of advertising capital spending across the state. |
| Sen. Comrie | high | supportive | MTA transparency and forensic audits Transit equity and affordability Rider representation on MTA Board Fair Fares expansion Capital project priorities | Sen. Comrie asked each panelist about their priority projects and emphasized the importance of transparency, equitability, and improved transportation. He requested another forensic audit of the MTA and expressed support for PCAC's affordability initiatives and Rider Representation Act. |
| Sen. Comrie | moderate | supportive | CHIPS funding support Upstate funding Winter extreme funding Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe road conditions | Sen. Comrie expressed strong support for CHIPS and upstate funding, pledging to fight for increased allocations. He acknowledged the egregious situation facing the Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe and committed to seeking relief for their road maintenance needs. |
| Sen. Comrie | moderate | supportive | Equitable resource distribution across communities MTA accessibility (ramps vs. elevators) Upstate support | Sen. Comrie expressed support for upstate colleagues and commitment to ensuring all communities receive deserved resources. He asked Greif clarifying questions about accessibility solutions and their cost-effectiveness. |
| Sen. Cooney | high | supportive | Worker safety and criminal penalties for assaults Work Zone Speed Camera Program effectiveness and permanence Signage and driver notification for speed cameras Revenue allocation from speed camera fines to Worker Safety Fund | Sen. Cooney expressed support for worker safety initiatives and the work zone speed camera program but raised concerns about excessive ticketing in Rochester (25,000 tickets in 24 days), questioning the balance between safety goals and driver notification. He sought clarification on how fine revenues would be allocated from the Worker Safety Fund lockbox. |
| Sen. Cordell Cleare | none | unclear | Sen. Cleare was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Jeremy Cooney | high | supportive | Worker safety Pavement materials and climate goals Public transportation and worker access Bus rapid transit expansion High-speed rail development Transit operating aid adequacy | Chair Cooney expressed strong support for the $800 million capital plan increase and worker safety initiatives. He focused on resilient pavement types, climate goals, and connecting underserved communities to economic opportunities through public transit. He proposed a new Worker Access Transit Fund and advocated for high-speed rail development, particularly a Toronto-to-New York corridor. He signaled concern that the 3.4 percent STOA increase may be insufficient for operational needs. |
| Sen. John C. Liu | none | unclear | Sen. Liu was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Krueger | high | skeptical | CLCPA compliance for capital projects Vehicle miles traveled reduction strategies Highway widening vs. climate goals Comptroller audit recommendations on Dedicated Highway and Bridge Trust Fund Design-build contracting evaluation Salt usage and environmental impacts Oversight and accountability | Chairwoman Krueger engaged extensively with Commissioner Dominguez on climate compliance, questioning whether DOT's capital projects align with CLCPA goals and whether highway expansion efforts conflict with vehicle miles traveled reduction targets. She praised the Comptroller's oversight role and asked pointed questions about design-build contracting effectiveness and salt management practices. |
| Sen. Krueger | high | supportive | Economic impact of MTA capital program Regional distribution of MTA spending ADA accessibility improvements Congestion pricing environmental impacts State funding commitments Fare increases prevention | Chairwoman Krueger demonstrated strong engagement with detailed questions about MTA's economic multiplier effects, regional equity in capital spending, accessibility progress, and environmental monitoring of congestion pricing. She expressed understanding of transit system importance and supported the $68 billion capital program as necessary investment. |
| Sen. Krueger | low | neutral | Hearing administration | Chairwoman Krueger managed portions of the hearing and introduced speakers but did not pose substantive questions to testifiers. |
| Sen. Krueger | high | skeptical | Moped registration and enforcement Unlicensed vehicles and illegal license plates Out-of-state vehicle registration fraud E-ZPass enforcement Vehicle inspection frequency EV charging infrastructure on Thruway | Sen. Krueger engaged extensively with both commissioners, asking pointed questions about enforcement mechanisms, data tracking capabilities, and implementation challenges. She expressed skepticism about whether new technology could address out-of-state registration fraud and questioned the necessity of annual vehicle inspections given modern car technology. She also pressed for faster EV charging deployment on the Thruway. |
| Sen. Krueger | high | neutral | Hearing administration Panel management Recognition of student attendees | Chairwoman Krueger co-chaired the hearing and managed panel introductions and timing. She recognized University Student Senate members and coordinated with other chairs but did not pose substantive questions to testifiers. |
| Sen. Krueger | moderate | supportive | Environmental sustainability and CLCPA requirements Construction materials and recycled content MTA accessibility programs | Sen. Krueger asked Epstein about progress on environmentally safe road construction materials and CLCPA compliance. She expressed interest in collaborative work on sustainable materials and acknowledged Greif's accessibility advocacy in her district. |
| Sen. Krueger | low | supportive | Krueger served as co-chair, thanked Greif for his testimony, and noted the importance of advocacy. | |
| Sen. Leroy Comrie | none | unclear | Sen. Comrie was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Leroy Comrie | high | supportive | DMV innovations and resources REAL ID compliance and public awareness E-ZPass billing errors and customer service High-speed internet expansion Toll comparisons Out-of-state vehicle inspections and insurance impacts Vehicle registration and inspection procedures | Sen. Comrie engaged extensively with both testifiers, thanking them for innovations while raising practical concerns about E-ZPass errors and proposing solutions like pop-up adjudication centers and amnesty programs. He expressed concern about out-of-state vehicles being inspected in New York and its impact on insurance costs. |
| Sen. Liu | moderate | supportive | State rail plan updates and Tier 1 EIS completion Federal Railroad Administration Corridor ID program Federal funding implications under new administration Amtrak service between NYC and Poughkeepsie | Sen. Liu thanked the Commissioner and praised Assistant Commissioners Ho and Gibbon. He focused on rail infrastructure progress, noting completion of Tier 1 EIS and application for Corridor ID funding. He inquired about potential impacts from the new federal administration on discretionary funding. |
| Sen. Liz Krueger | moderate | neutral | Hearing administration and procedural matters | Chair Krueger presided over the hearing and introduced Senate members. She did not ask substantive questions during the portion of the transcript provided. |
| Sen. Magnarelli | moderate | neutral | Ongoing stakeholder engagement beyond budget season | Sen. Magnarelli thanked all testifiers for their participation and expressed appreciation for continued communication with his office throughout the year, not just during budget season. |
| Sen. Martinez | moderate | skeptical | Long Island project completion and commencement status Southern State Parkway safety and expansion Meadowbrook expansion Northern State Parkway expansion Oakdale Merge project | Sen. Martinez followed up on Long Island funding concerns raised by colleagues. She emphasized that Long Island and Hudson Valley have the worst street and pavement conditions and pressed for details on major projects. She highlighted the Southern State Parkway as one of the deadliest highways in New York and advocated for on- and off-ramp improvements. |
| Sen. Monica R. Martinez | none | unclear | Sen. Martinez was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. O'Mara | moderate | skeptical | Inflation adjustment in capital plan ($800 million) Justification for flat CHIPS, PAVE-NY, BRIDGE NY funding despite inflation Electric vehicle weight standards and road infrastructure readiness | Sen. O'Mara thanked DOT for flood response and community assistance. He questioned the logic of adding $800 million for inflation to the state capital plan while keeping local programs flat, arguing local governments face the same inflationary pressures. He sought clarification on EV weight standards and road readiness. |
| Sen. O'Mara | moderate | supportive | Railcar manufacturing in Southern Tier of New York Alstom in Hornell, CAF in Elmira, Siemens in Horseheads M-9A commuter rail contract procurement timeline Legislative tools to prioritize New York State manufacturing | Sen. O'Mara advocated for prioritizing New York State railcar manufacturers and pressed for resolution of the nine-year M-9A procurement process. He offered legislative support to facilitate manufacturing in the state. |
| Sen. O'Mara | high | supportive | CHIPS funding advocacy Program consolidation Fair distribution of funding Rural community needs | Sen. O'Mara expressed strong support for the $250 million CHIPS increase request and praised CHIPS as the fairest distribution program in the state. He emphasized the critical importance of CHIPS for rural towns and villages that rely on it as their sole highway funding source and committed to working hard to achieve the additional funding. |
| Sen. Oberacker | high | skeptical | CHIPS funding flatness and proposed CLEAR emergency assistance program Service life requirements for CHIPS-funded projects Electric vehicle infrastructure challenges for emergency vehicles, school buses, and plows Green hydrogen rail project proposal Safety zones and speeding enforcement | Sen. Oberacker expressed concern about flat funding for CHIPS and other local programs. He proposed a $62 million CLEAR program ($1 million per county) as a bridge solution and suggested reducing service life requirements from 10 to 8 years for CHIPS eligibility. He advocated for EV carveouts for emergency and municipal vehicles and promoted a green hydrogen rail project for the Catskills region. |
| Sen. Persaud | low | supportive | Responsiveness of DOT staff to constituent issues | Sen. Persaud publicly thanked Commissioner Dominguez and his staff for their responsiveness to constituent concerns, including issues with pigeons in her district, signaling a collaborative relationship. |
| Sen. Persaud | moderate | opposed | Express bus service reliability, specifically BM2 Bus scheduling and customer service | Sen. Persaud raised concerns about chronic delays on the BM2 express bus and poor customer service, characterizing her district as a transit desert. She pressed for management accountability on bus scheduling and criticized the customer service call line. |
| Sen. Persaud | moderate | supportive | Broadway Junction Station progress Elevator and accessibility work timeline | Persaud sought specific updates on Broadway Junction Station accessibility work and thanked Greif for his advocacy efforts and regular communications. |
| Sen. Peter Oberacker | none | unclear | Sen. Oberacker was listed as present as ranking member on Transportation but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Pretlow | high | skeptical | State Touring Route program funding Lower Hudson Valley transit study Tappan Zee Bridge rail service potential Hudson Tunnel project and Bergen Loop | Chair Pretlow questioned the necessity and allocation of the $40 million State Touring Route program and the $1 million Lower Hudson Valley transit study, suggesting funds could be better used for CHIPS. He expressed skepticism about the value of the transit study but acknowledged interest in rail service across the Tappan Zee Bridge. |
| Sen. Pretlow | high | supportive | Bus schedule adjustments post-congestion pricing Police deployment on buses vs. trains MTA fare comparisons to other systems Casino revenue allocation to MTA Local spending and job creation Congestion pricing traffic flow impacts | Chair Pretlow demonstrated strong engagement with detailed follow-up questions about operational impacts of congestion pricing, particularly regarding bus schedule adjustments and traffic flow. He expressed support for MTA capital investment and local job creation, while pressing for accountability on casino revenue allocation and questioning the effectiveness of police deployment strategies. |
| Sen. Pretlow | moderate | neutral | Hearing administration Time management for testimony | Sen. Pretlow served as chair and managed the hearing flow, allocating time to speakers and maintaining order. He did not pose substantive questions to testifiers. |
| Sen. Pretlow | high | supportive | REAL ID requirements and federal compliance E-bike and motorized vehicle regulation Fake license plates and enforcement Thruway lane marking reflectiveness and safety Speeding ticket revenue distribution DMV service improvements | Sen. Pretlow engaged extensively with DMV Commissioner Schroeder and Thruway Authority officials, praising DMV improvements while questioning federal REAL ID requirements and raising concerns about unregulated e-bikes and fake license plates. He advocated for more reflective lane markings on the Thruway and requested a test program to evaluate safety improvements. |
| Sen. Pretlow | high | neutral | Hearing administration Panel management | Chairman Pretlow co-chaired the hearing, managed questioning order, and maintained hearing decorum. He did not pose substantive questions but facilitated other legislators' engagement. |
| Sen. Pretlow | high | neutral | Hearing administration Panel management Acknowledgment of testimony | Sen. Pretlow chaired the hearing and managed panel introductions and transitions. He thanked testifiers for their testimony and acknowledged the value of their information. |
| Sen. Pretlow | low | neutral | Pretlow served as chair, managing the hearing flow and formally closing the session. | |
| Sen. Roxanne Persaud | none | unclear | Sen. Persaud was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Roxanne Persaud | moderate | supportive | REAL ID compliance and outreach Mobile office program expansion County partnerships | Sen. Persaud commended DMV efforts on REAL ID outreach and asked supportive questions about expanding mobile office services and county partnerships. She reinforced messaging about REAL ID compliance deadlines. |
| Sen. Siela A. Bynoe | none | unclear | Sen. Bynoe was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Thomas F. O'Mara | none | unclear | Sen. O'Mara was listed as present but did not ask questions in the transcript provided. | |
| Sen. Tom O'Mara | high | skeptical | Advanced Clean Truck Rule implementation Medium- and heavy-duty EV charging infrastructure Electrical power availability and limitations Charging times and vehicle range Safety upgrades for heavier vehicles Guardrail replacement costs | Sen. O'Mara, the ranking member, posed pointed and confrontational questions about the feasibility of EV charging infrastructure given the Advanced Clean Truck Rule is already in effect. He pressed Director Hoare on timelines, power availability, and safety concerns, signaling skepticism about the state's readiness for electrification mandates. |